Rewindera Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of rewindera.com

Rewindera Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of rewindera.com

Rewindera reviews

Showing 19 reviews with 3 stars · Clear filters

Shawn K.
Sep 29, 2026
Great concept and style, but size and exchange challenges
I was so excited about the shirt I ordered and so disappointed when it arrived and was significantly larger than expected. I ordered a medium (since they note on their website that their sizes run large), but it was still huge. I contacted them to initiate an exchange, only to be disappointed again--their exchange could only be done by paying (a reduced price) for another shirt. Still, I love the shirt, so I initiated the exchange. When I received the small size shirt, it was too tight. There is a vast difference between their small and medium sizes, but somehow, I don't fit in it. Now, I have to very fun shirts in my closet that do not fit and I will never wear. :(
Response from RewinderaSep 29, 2026
We’re truly sorry that neither size provided a comfortable fit, especially after you went through the exchange process. We understand how disappointing it is to have two shirts you love but cannot wear. Thank you for sharing this feedback, which we will take seriously as we continue improving our sizing guidance.
Report
Judy H.
Jul 28, 2026
Looks great; feels not so great
The printing is great and the pattern lines up almost perfectly along the zipper in the front. The texture of the exterior sweatshirt fabric is unpleasantly synthetic. I was most disappointed with the packaging -- THREE layers of plastic is not necessary!
Response from RewinderaJul 29, 2026
Thank you for your honest feedback. We're glad to hear you were happy with the print quality and how well the pattern aligned. We're sorry the fabric and packaging didn't meet your expectations. Your comments about the material and reducing plastic packaging are valuable, and we'll share them with our team as we continue to improve.
Report
Melinda C.
Jun 1, 2026
Beware of No Returns/Exchanges Policy
I purchased matching shirts for my husband and myself. His fit well, although he didn't particularly like the fabric (100% ployester). My shirt hung to mid-thigh and was not flattering at all, I will never wear it. I will admit that the problem I had was partly my own because I didn't read their return policy. They do not accept returns. When I contacted them they did offer to sell me something else at a discounted price. Having spent almost $40 on a shirt I'll never wear, I declined.
Response from RewinderaJun 2, 2026
Thank you for sharing your experience. We’re glad to hear your husband’s shirt fit well and that you were able to reach our team for assistance. We’re sorry that your shirt didn’t fit the way you expected and understand how disappointing that can be. As a made-to-order company, we have specific policies regarding returns and exchanges, but we always try to offer alternative solutions whenever possible. We appreciate your feedback and your honest review.
Report
Molly P.
May 15, 2026
2 totes - one great, one not
I bought two tote bags. They took about two weeks to arrive, which was fine. I love one and the other not so much. The material for the bags seems heavy-duty, so I like that. The printed image on one of them seems printed too high with a large space at the bottom, like it is obvious it wasn't centered well. The other has more of a collage-style print and it looks great.
Response from RewinderaMay 16, 2026
Thank you for your thoughtful feedback. We’re glad to hear you liked the durability of the tote bags and loved one of the designs. We’re sorry the print placement on the other bag didn’t meet your expectations, and we appreciate you pointing that out. Your comments are very helpful and will be shared with our team as we continue improving our print quality and consistency.
Report
Martin H.
Apr 29, 2026
Bonanza shirt good, bad, and ooogly.
Loved the Bonanza shirt. However if it was not a Bonanza fever buy I would never have ordered a poly plastic icky summer shirt let alone pay cotton premium shirt price for such sub par material. Buttttt for Bonanza fever... Won't ever wear it, but will probably hang it in the man cave or make a flag out if it. Make it out of cotton and I'll buy one to wear.
Response from RewinderaApr 30, 2026
Thank you for your honest and thoughtful feedback. We’re glad to hear you loved the Bonanza design — that one’s definitely special. We’re sorry the material wasn’t what you were hoping for, and we really appreciate your suggestion about offering a cotton option. We’ll be sure to share this with our team as we continue improving our products.
Report
Andrew J.
Apr 28, 2026
Great design, lousy shirt
Great design, low quality shirt
Response from RewinderaApr 29, 2026
Thank you for your feedback. We’re glad you liked the design, though we’re sorry the shirt quality didn’t meet your expectations. Your comments are helpful and will be shared with our team as we continue improving.
Report
darbywing
Apr 23, 2026
Made of polyester....
The shirt came very well printed with reasonable shipping cost. The material of the shirt is an extremely poor choice for a garment. It may print well, but polyester is a horrible material to wear. It is extremely sticky and does not breathe. Had I known it was polyester, I would not have ordered it. This is likely the reason the material is not disclosed in the advertisement.
Response from RewinderaApr 23, 2026
Thank you for your feedback. We’re glad to hear the print quality and shipping met your expectations, but we’re sorry the material wasn’t what you were hoping for. Our product pages do list the fabric details, and we understand that material preference can vary from person to person. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience — it helps us continue improving.
Report
Dennis
Apr 11, 2026
The product was as pictured
The product was as pictured, but I would say that the quality of the fabric was fair to poor. I will keep the item, but I will not be reordering form the vendor again,
Response from RewinderaApr 12, 2026
Thank you for your feedback. We’re glad the product matched what you saw online, but we’re sorry to hear the fabric didn’t meet your expectations. Your comments are helpful and will be shared with our team as we continue improving.
Report