Teresa W.
Treated with respect
I came to the the store at a busy time with some drama from a neighboring business, but was still treated with respect.

View our large selection of jewelry, watches, and coins.
Puyallup Diamond & Gold Buyers (puyallupgoldbuyers.com) has 89 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Spokane, Washington
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · Bellevue, Washington
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · Issaquah, Washington
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Seattle, Washington
Excellent
89 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Teresa W.
I came to the the store at a busy time with some drama from a neighboring business, but was still treated with respect.
Scott G.
I visited this well-established business located near South Hill mall for over 15 years. I worked with Erica who is very friendly, knowledgeable, and professional. She thoroughly explained the appraisal process, pricing, and payment process. Erica was great to work with offering advice when requested, and providing a pleasant, no pressure experience.
Sue
professional and knowledgeable make the process easy and prices are very good
ETPhoneHome
I took several pieces of jewelry to get appraised and evaluated for sale. The appraiser seemed very honest and explained that today only Gold is worth something, no longer are diamonds or emeralds worth much. Due to economy and due to now Diamonds can be man made perfectly and cheaper. This is what many of the shops explain.
Lonna W.
I’m very please. I felt that I was being taken good care of. I did bring my stuff home pondering whether I wanted to sell it or not and you guys did offer to buy it from me and I was offered by you guys about $1000. I have silver and some collectible pieces and a really nice piece of jewelry. So I was thinking about coming back to see if the offer is still good. You can feel free to message me and let me know if you have an availability maybe on Monday morning or something? Thank you so much Lonna Walden 253.778.2383
Tom D.
Great place to take your gold and silver. They gave me very fair pricing and explained things so I understood. The lady who runs the shop is extremely nice. They will get all of my future business.
Kristi K.
This buyer is a scam. They will not pay a fair price. 9 ounces of gold sells for $36000. I was offered less than $800. She is taking advantage of desperate people.
Response from Puyallup Diamond & Gold BuyersJan 18, 2026
Hello Kristi, We have reviewed our camera surveillance footage and can clearly confirm that the ring you brought in weighed 9 grams, not ounces. There is a significant difference in value between grams and ounces, which directly affects pricing. Additionally, the ring was not pure gold. You asked for the market value of the ring, and we provided our professional assessment while fully explaining how the value was determined. Calling our business a “scam buyer” is unwarranted and inaccurate, as we did nothing wrong. We are a small, locally owned business and take pride in operating transparently and honestly. We respectfully ask that you update or remove your review to reflect the accurate information.
Natalie B.
2nd time coming in and honestly has always been very nice and generous. They give really good offers and help very much.