Amanda
Cancels Appraisals
They cancelled my free appraisal appointment by email and I called to reschedule but they never called back. Apparently they don't want to give out the free appraisals they advertise or don't want my business.

View our large selection of jewelry, watches, and coins.
Puyallup Diamond & Gold Buyers (puyallupgoldbuyers.com) has 89 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Spokane, Washington
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · Bellevue, Washington
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · Issaquah, Washington
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Seattle, Washington
Excellent
Showing 9 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
Amanda
They cancelled my free appraisal appointment by email and I called to reschedule but they never called back. Apparently they don't want to give out the free appraisals they advertise or don't want my business.
tim_mcalisterhotmail.com
Horrible with communication. Tried several times to reach them via message through website, emails to 3 addresses, and phone. Ultimately ended up with them cancelling my appointment with them with an hour notice asking me to reschedule. No, get bent. Horrible business practices send people elsewhere to businesses that pride themselves with good and exceptional customer service. I do not and will not EVER recommend them.
Kristie B.
I made an appointment and no one was there. When I text this company they said they didn’t see my appointment but sent me a reminder. I was contacted back but was not offered to reschedule my free appraisal. I never purchased anything from this company
Kristi K.
This buyer is a scam. They will not pay a fair price. 9 ounces of gold sells for $36000. I was offered less than $800. She is taking advantage of desperate people.
Response from Puyallup Diamond & Gold BuyersJan 18, 2026
Hello Kristi, We have reviewed our camera surveillance footage and can clearly confirm that the ring you brought in weighed 9 grams, not ounces. There is a significant difference in value between grams and ounces, which directly affects pricing. Additionally, the ring was not pure gold. You asked for the market value of the ring, and we provided our professional assessment while fully explaining how the value was determined. Calling our business a “scam buyer” is unwarranted and inaccurate, as we did nothing wrong. We are a small, locally owned business and take pride in operating transparently and honestly. We respectfully ask that you update or remove your review to reflect the accurate information.
Jerel T.
I ordered some silver 12/2/25. The confirmation email said I should receive the items in 5-10 business days, and that I would be notified when the item shipped. I emailed them on the 9th business day inquiring about the status of my order as I have not heard from them. I did not receive a response. Ironically enough, this survey arrived the 10th business day since my pre-paid order. So apparently I cannot get any info as to why my order hasn’t shipped (I’m local so it should’ve already arrived), but I can get asked to fill out a customer satisfaction survey 🤷♂️
Melissa
Nobody showed up for scheduled appointment even though they emailed to confirm. Nobody answered the phone when I called, and I haven’t there’s been no word from them since then (last week!). I left 2 phone messages and an email.
Steve R.
Terrible. Felt unsafe
W R.
Zero stars, they did not show up for my appointment.