College B.
Out of 7 essays, I got 1 Excellent Editor and 6 Average Ones
I had 5 essays reviewed by Prompt. I did 1 review/each for 4 of the essays and for the main Common App essay I did 3 reviews with 3 different editors. I noted that I was applying to a highly selective school and I welcomed any level of edits - even rewrites if necessary. Of the 7 editors who worked on my essay, I feel like only 1 made impactful revisions. The others made some suggestions that included answering lengthy questions that would have easily made me go over my word count by 50%. On one of my essays I even paid extra for "rush" service and I certainly got revisions that seemed too rushed. It didn't seem like the editor put much thought in the edit, didn't leave many comments and I knew my essay probably could've used a lot more edits. I wish there was a way to request an editor that you have worked with before. I got one good one and I wish I could work with her again. I think these editors are fine if you are only looking for minor edits, grammar checks, edits for flow. If you are looking for more dramatic improvements in your essay, this probably isn't for you.




