Only Natural Pet offers natural pet supplies for dogs and cats. Natural Pet Food, Flea Remedies, Dog Supplements & Homeopathic Remedies as well as articles & information on holistic pet health care.
Only Natural Pet (onlynaturalpet.com) has 46 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 1.9 out of 5.
Also known as
onlynaturalpet.com
Website
onlynaturalpet.com
Category
Pet Stores
Location
Boulder, Colorado
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company has not replied to any reviews yet.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
⭐ 1 Star Review
I’ve had a very frustrating experience with Only Natural Pet. I’m enrolled in their auto-ship program, which has always delivered 4 items—until last month, when I only received 3 with no explanation.
On top of that, the last two auto-ship orders I received included products that were already expired. That’s completely unacceptable when it comes to pet food and supplies.
I reached out to customer service via email to resolve these issues, but never received any response. No follow-up, no accountability.
Between incorrect orders, expired products, and zero customer support, I’ve completely lost trust in this company. I will no longer be using Only Natural Pet moving forward. I expected much better reliability and quality.
JE
Jelka
I have terible experience with this website
I have terible experience with this company. Never order anything from their website and never left any personal information or bank account on their website. They will charge you and their costumer services will not serve to you.
JJ
Jodi J.
⭐️ 1 Star
⭐️ 1 Star – Extremely Frustrating and Unethical Subscription Practices
I canceled my subscription with Only Natural Pet months ago, yet they continue to send me food and charge my account almost $82 each time. When I called customer service, I was told that I had “only canceled a delivery, not the subscription.” Their website is extremely confusing and not user-friendly, and it honestly feels intentionally designed that way to trap customers into staying subscribed.
The reason I canceled in the first place was because my dogs had to be switched to a different food. The only reason I even looked for an alternative was because Only Natural Pet’s deliveries consistently took forever to arrive, leaving me waiting far too long for food I needed on time.
When I called about the most recent charge and asked for a refund, I was told I would have to refuse delivery or ship the product back before they would refund me. While I understand policies, this completely ignores real life. Between work and daily responsibilities, the last thing I want—or have time—to do is drive to a post office, wait in line, and send something back just to get my own money refunded. That means nearly $82 out of my account for weeks, and in today’s economy, that’s money I absolutely need.
On top of all of this, customer service was rude and dismissive, and I believe one representative actually hung up on me. I’ve worked in customer service my entire life, and courtesy refunds are commonly given—especially when the company is clearly at fault.
This experience has been stressful, time-consuming, and financially damaging. I would strongly caution anyone considering a subscription with this company.
NE
NervousNancy
Suspicious
My dog's food was out of stock so I searched and this co came up. Never heard of this co. Price seemed ok but description and photo differed greatly in weight, so I looked for a phone #. Called them and someone answered and then hung up right away. Then noticed all the reviews for the product are copies from the Dr. Marty website. Every, single, one. Next to the description was a review telling me if I was unsure of this company to "trust them". Too many suspicious things in a row. Don't think so. Not going to chance giving them my credit card info.
JS
Joy S.
Only Natural Pet automatically put you…
Only Natural Pet automatically put you on auto-ship, something I didn’t know when I ordered. I normally buy a 12.5 lb bag of food. That size was out of stock from the manufacturer so I bought a 4 lb bag from here. A little over 3 weeks later I got an email saying my order was filled. I called within 2 hours of receiving that email to say I didn’t want it, please cancel. I was told it was too late even though it hadn’t left the building. I was told I would get a return label for the order. It took a second call to actually get that label. I sent back the order. I have now found that they charged me $6 shipping that was not refunded, even though I canceled BEFORE it was shipped.
OR
Oscar R.
DO NOT sign up for auto-ship!
DO NOT sign up for auto-ship!! There is NO WAY to cancel!!! You can change the product, change the date, change the frequency, but what you CANNOT do, is cancel. Dog dies? Ohh well, here's another bag of food. Don’t need it anymore? Too bad, you signed up for auto ship 12 years ago, were going to keep sending it until you die, then your heirs will get it, because YOU CAN'T CANCEL OUR AUTO SHIP!!!
AY
ayre
Terrible customer service
Terrible customer service. They don’t know questipns about the products they’re selling, they don’t accept returns on closed packages. They don’t reason with you. Is not my first time dealing with them. They have sent replacements of products i needed for my dog with things i would never use
VL
Vivi L.
Really really terrible customer service…
Really really terrible customer service and a real lack of a system that respects consumer rights. Two great issues: 1) My order never came. It was time sensitive. I listed it when ordering. Just kept receiving automated messages and no real customer service. 2) Bombarded by ONLY NATURAL PET emails, I must have "unsubscribed" at least half a dozen times. Still being bombarded. Total lack of respect for consumers rights and real customer service. Seems there is no "human" behind this mass production machine.