Custom stuffed animals of your pets! Petsies makes custom pet keepsakes for any pet, including Custom Plushies, Pillows, Blankets, Figurines, Pajamas, and more!
Petsies (mypetsies.com) has 290 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Also known as
mypetsies.com
Website
mypetsies.com
Category
Children's Entertainment
Location
Boynton Beach, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 67% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I purchased a petsie of my deceased sphynx cat. The unique spots and colors were captured perfectly. They did a good job with the fabic and sewn in wrinkles. The problem is they have a template body shape for all cats. Sphynx cats do not have the same bodies as other cats. Their head shape, mouth, large ears, long elongated limbs are thin wiry tales are unique to their breed. Putting sphynx "fur" on a regular cat body looks all wrong. It is very silly looking. Much like they have different forms for specific breeds of dogs, they need to offer cat forms for different breeds of cats. I would also like to see an option to have your pet curled up and sleeping. Closed eyes should be an option. They did a great job with what they had but if you have a sphyx or any other unique breed of cat, I would not recommend
Response from PetsiesMay 15, 2025
Hi Arya!
We really appreciate the review and feedback on the shape and fur of the cats. I'll be sure to pass that information along to our team. Regardless, we appreciate your review and hope you still were satisfied with your Petsie!
-The Petsies Team
CS
Celia S.
I was hoping for the brown around her…
I was hoping for the brown around her tail to be represented and it was not. Otherwise she looks great.
JN
Judy N.
A bit pricy for what you get.
For the amount I paid, I honestly expected a thicker blanket. It was a memento gift for someone and it looked cheaper than what I knew was the cost. The photo picture wasn't as defined as I hoped, so I was disappointed in this purchase.
Petsies reply still disappoints. I did not order the cheapest possible blanket, but a medium size one. For the price I paid, it should have been more substantial. I doubt the recipient realizes this.
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi Judy!
We're sorry to hear that you weren't totally pleased with your blanket. We do offer multiple options for material/thickness levels at varying costs and see that you had chosen Arctic Pro Fleece, which is the base option. As for the picture, we do apologize that it was not as clear as you had hoped. It is possible the file was not large enough for the blanket size chosen, and had to be stretched a bit.
Nonetheless, we hope that you and the person you gifted the blanket to were still satisfied with it, and we do appreciate the review!
-The Petsies Team
JM
James M.
Difficult experience, but they tried. Very high quality.
This is a difficult experience to rate. We ordered a stuffed animal replica of our cat who passed on, but since our cat was a basic black cat without much in the way of distinguishing features, I was worried we would get a "generic black cat" plush. I sent pictures and explained her unique features, and...I got a generic black cat plush. It looked very little like my cat. I got in touch with customer service who offered to remake it, there was a bit of confusion about what I wanted (they felt the problem was I thought it was too big, but that was a secondary issue) but they agreed to remake it in a smaller size for no additional cost. The remake took a very long time, but they did offer to let me keep the first attempt (I chose to send it back to them). When we got the second attempt, it was much better. Not perfect, but they clearly made an attempt, and it definitely captures her "essence" more than the first one.
I will say this stuffed animal (both the original and the remake) are *extremely* high quality. The fur feels realistic, it looks amazing, and several times I've looked at it and thought my cat was back and sitting on her couch. Our other cat has even been fooled by it. They're not cheap, but they are an amazing product and definitely a fitting memorial to our cat.
I kept flipping between 3 and 4, but the main reason I settled on 3 is because they are in the business of dealing with people who have lost pets, people who cared enough about their pets to want something to remember them by. Quite simply, their first attempt was extremely upsetting, I wanted something that looked like my cat and it was *not* my cat. They fixed their mistake and I may be being a bit too judgmental, the loss was still very new. And quite honestly, while I admit I was partly at fault because I was very upset, their customer service was not very friendly or understanding.
I'd still recommend their product, especially if your pet has distinctive markings or something they can more easily replicate. Just be ready if things don't end up the way you expect.
Response from PetsiesApr 18, 2025
Hi, James!
First off, we're sorry the production and perfection of the Petsie took so long, but we're very glad that you were pleased with it in the end! We know that it can take a bit of time, especially when there's a remake involved, as these are custom products. But this is to try to capture every detail and replicate each pet's likeness as much as possible!
With that being said, we really are glad you were happy with it in the end. We really appreciate the kind words about the quality of your Petsie, and we're honored that we were able to help you feel a bit more connected with your cat again.
DK
Dilek K.
The face doesn't match at all
The face doesn't match at all, only the eye color is correct. Overall, the tomcat is too big. The paw color doesn't match either. Definitely not worth €260.
Response from PetsiesJul 9, 2024
Dilek,
I’m so sorry to hear that you’re unhappy with your Petsie of Boncuk. Our team does our best to match your pet as closely as we can, but please keep in mind that they are not exact replicas. You selected the 16 inch size option, which is the size we made and sent you. We are sorry you don’t feel that the coloring matches exactly.
Please email our team at [email protected] and we’d love to help find a solution for you.
-The Petsies Team
KM
KML
I love my Petsi but....
I love my Petsi. The problem I have is that he had long hair and the Petsie has medium hair that is scraggly. His nose area was black when it arrived but has turned whiteish which freaks me out. He had very long white whiskers that was his most prominent feature and the Petsie is very lacking in that. His nose was also normal but the Petsie looks like more of a dog's nose but I can live with that. His black legs are also turning whiteish. I love my Petsie because it does remind me of my Whiskers. I guess if you want the most accurate you need to pay over $600 so you can see what they are doing before they send it to you.
Response from PetsiesFeb 15, 2024
Hello,
Thank you for your review. We are very surprised to see that you are not 100% happy with the fur length of your Petsie. :( Our team has not received a direct message from you regarding these areas of concerns. We encourage you to reach out to our team so that we may offer some options to better meet your expectations. :)
-The Petsies Team
NT
Nicole T.
Custom Order
I had a custom order made of my sisters dog and the face looks nothing like her, the body is adequate but the head is totally wrong. My sister still loved it, even my other dogs sort of recognize it but the face is definitely not the same.
Response from PetsiesJan 11, 2024
Hi Nicole, thanks for your review. I’m sorry the plush didn’t come out as you expected it to, but I am glad your sister and dogs are loving it! If you do think we missed a specific detail, there are some things that we can alter at our main facility. Please email [email protected] if you’d like to chat with one of our customer service reps about this. Thanks!
KR
Kari R.
Made things right
They made it right, and the solution was good
------------------------------------------------------
I have photos. They completely delivered a bad product that doesn't even resemble the species let alone specific pet. They have a return policy regarding design disagreements not being valid. This isn't a design disagreement. It's pure bad quality work proven. It's not a design issue, it's a skill issue. I realize I paid for a sneak peek but was on a family emergency and only given a 72 hour window so I could not take advantage of that. Regardless, it shouldn't take a preview to at least make this look like a cat.