Holly
I had a really disappointing experience…
I had a really disappointing experience with this company. I ordered a wine and golf–themed gift basket for my manager, based on the product photos and description on their website. What was delivered looked nothing like what was advertised. Instead of a golf-themed cookie, they included a Christmas cookie — completely off theme and inappropriate for the professional setting this was meant for. When I contacted customer service, they justified it by saying substitutions are allowed and that I agreed to their terms and conditions. I understand substitutions for unavailable items, but this was not a similar replacement. The entire theme and presentation of the basket was different, which defeats the purpose of ordering a themed gift in the first place. Rather than taking accountability, they essentially implied I should be grateful they delivered it quickly and that I shouldn’t expect a refund — even though it did not resemble what I ordered. Extremely disappointing customer service and misleading product presentation. I would not recommend this company if you’re expecting to receive what you actually paid for.
Response from Monthly SommelierNov 22, 2025
We’re truly sorry to hear about your experience with your gift basket order. We completely understand how important it is for a themed gift to match what is advertised, especially for a professional setting. It’s clear that the substitution we provided did not meet your expectations, and we sincerely apologize for the mismatch and the frustration it caused. Your feedback is valuable, and we take it seriously. While substitutions are sometimes necessary, it’s never our intention for them to compromise the theme or presentation of a gift. Our team has already reached out to you to discuss a possible resolution, and we hope to find a way to make this right. Thank you for bringing this to our attention, and we hope to restore your trust in us.




