Traditional dating is back in style for selective singlesAt The Matchmaking Company, our decades of matchmaking experience has taught us to stop chasing dating or technology trends, and focus on what really matters - our clients.Here is what we offer our clients.It’s our mission to get to know you, understand your relationship goals, and what you feel is most important in an ideal match. Using our time-tested process, our expert team of Professional Matchmakers will curate potential matches who they think share your key life values, interests, and life goals. With our private and secure process, you can date confidently. Stop wasting time or waiting for love to happen to you. Every Client has a Background ScreeningRelationship-Minded SinglesNo Wasted Time on Fake ProfilesGet Matched on Key Life ValuesYears of Personal Matchmaking SuccessLocal Offices and Local Singles Empower. Date. Find Love. Our matchmakers are passionate about your success and it shows in all they do!Our Company ValuesAuthenticityOur teams pride themselves on not only creating authentic, lasting relationships but also building authentic connections with their clients every step of the matchmaking journey.PassionWe lead with passion and integrity. The business is fueled on the passion of the people who work here, as well as the passionate connections we love creating.ProfessionalWe are a highly qualified team who believe in investing in each other, themselves, and their clients every step of the way to ensure curated lasting introductions.
The Matchmaking Company (matchmakingcompany.com) has 457 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.8 out of 5.
Also known as
matchmakingcompany.com
Website
matchmakingcompany.com
Category
Adult Entertainment
Location
Broken Arrow, Oklahoma
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 100% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
This company is a scam fraudulent company targeting unsuspecting Reno locals. Please search the case RSC2026-000598 in Reno Justice Court for the open case. I only hope if you’re searching this you have not met with or done anything with this fraudulent horrific company. I will be working to ensure everyone in the area knows the terrible company this is. They changed their name from Sierra Matchmakers after repeated horrible reviews to try to get away from their notorious reputation. This is a nationwide scam ring.
There are Nevada legal requirements about concealing material facts, giving misleading information and high pressure tactics.
I cancelled same day within hours without their sales rep ever validating my identity which they state is a strict requirement to membership so obviously no services provided and they still charged my card 4 days after, 3k and then after being emailed called sent certified mail tried to decline cancellation. I live in Washoe and will repost the case number so you can be sure to look up the facts yourself. BEWARE of this scam business
Nevada NRS 598.0915(5) — a person engages in a deceptive trade practice if they knowingly make “a false representation as to the characteristics, ingredients, uses, benefits, alterations or quantities of goods or services for sale.” Corroborating reviews from other customers with the same complaint help establish this was knowing — a pattern, not a one-off exaggeration.
2. Misrepresentation about when the contract took effect
NRS 598.0923(2) — a deceptive trade practice includes when a business “fails to disclose a material fact in connection with the sale… of services.” Being told the contract wouldn’t be effective until the next business day, then hearing something contrary once you tried to cancel before that date, is a misrepresentation of a material fact about your own agreement — separate from any statutory cancellation window.
This also stands on its own as a basic contract-formation argument outside any statute: their own agent’s statement about the effective date is part of the deal, and you acted (cancelled) within the window she gave you.
3. Zero services rendered
No specific consumer-protection statute needed here — this is ordinary breach of contract and unjust enrichment under Nevada common law: they took payment, provided nothing, and didn’t refund despite a timely cancellation attempt.
4. Remedy / private right of action
NRS 598.0915–598.0925, enforced through the consumer-fraud private right of action, lets a prevailing party recover damages plus costs and reasonable attorney’s fees — meaningful leverage in small claims or beyond. affairs
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 14, 2026
Dai, we respectfully disagree with the statements made in your review.
The Matchmaking Company takes its legal obligations seriously and conducts business in accordance with the laws applicable to our industry. The Nevada statute referenced in your review does not govern private matchmaking service agreements, and we do not agree with your interpretation of its applicability.
We wish you the very best moving forward.
MH
MELISSA H.
I would definitely NOT recommend this…
I would definitely NOT recommend this dating service. I signed up March 6, 2026 and have had 1 legitimate date!!!! It is now almost July 1st and they have literally ghosted Me. Whenever I reach out I’m sent the same automated message!!
I'm a client that's retired and always available to go on a date 24/7!!
In addition to the one date I had, several months ago, the following reasons below should be enough for you to run, not walk, away from this company:
1. There's a total lack of communication on the matchmaking companies matchmakers to reach out unless YOU reach out and even then, I'm still waiting for a 2nd date for almost 2 months!! When I signed up they stated “ that there were so many men in my age range and what I was looking for!!”
The reason I joined this expensive and promising company was to avoid dating APPS and to meet quality men. Now, I signed up with several dating apps and meeting several quality men and going on dates weekly!!
3. Their costs are very high for the service promised and provided.
The more YOU call them, the more they change your agreements and/ or their guidelines, as to information they can share about their clients or your potential dates!!
So, don’t waste your time and money on this overpriced and under experienced company…. Join the apps and surround yourself in places where you’ll meet quality people and you will!!
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 30, 2026
Melissa, thank you for sharing your feedback. We're sorry to hear that your experience has not met your expectations.
We want to clarify a few points for anyone reading your review. Since joining in March 2026, you have received two introductions. While you chose not to meet your first introduction, we continued our search and provided another introduction approximately one month ago, which falls within the typical timeframe for personalized matchmaking.
Our records also reflect that we have remained in regular communication with you throughout your membership. We respectfully disagree with the statement that you have been "ghosted."
Our goal is not to move quickly through a membership by providing introductions simply for the sake of meeting a number. We believe quality is more important than quantity, and our Matchmakers take the time to identify individuals whom they believe have genuine compatibility based on each client's preferences, values, and relationship goals.
We appreciate your feedback and remain committed to helping you find a meaningful connection.
SS
Suzie S.
Hard core pressure to buy, lied to me put me in harms way
Hard core pressure to "purchase" a service. Advertised timelines are not met. They did not READ my file. Deal Breakers for me were: I did not want to be a Nurse, I did not want to be a Purse, and specific on Politics.
Matchmaker called with a "date". First off the Politics was totally unacceptable. Pressure to go on the date anyway. I agreed to meet this person. Matchmaker called back 5 minutes later to tell me this man had a stroke, and not to be worried. I stated again, I do not want to take care of anyone. She said he was fine, didn't need any help, etc. When the man called me I could not understand him, because his speech was affected by the stroke. Not good. I agreed to meet and asked him how I would recognize him. He said he was in a wheelchair. I CANCELLED the date. I asked for my money back, several times. Very upset. Two weeks later another Matchmaker called me with a new date. I said I wanted my money back, he said I would never get it. Later the first Matchmaker called me back to calm me down. Said she had the perfect date, hard core pressure to accept. They are suppose to vet all clients for background - fraud, crimes, bankrupts, etc. I agreed to have lunch with this man. All he did was talk about himself, his ex wife, his deceased girlfriend. Very pushy Never asked one question about me. The next day I texted him to politely say I was not interested. Then I started getting threatening texts. I reported this to the Matchmaker - I printed out all the texts. I asked for my money back, she said I would never get it. I do not trust these people, they lied to me, they put me in harms way. Do Not Ever use this company.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 30, 2026
Suzie, thank you for sharing your feedback. We're sorry to hear that you remain dissatisfied with your experience.
We respectfully disagree with several statements made in your review. Throughout your membership, our team worked to identify introductions based on the preferences, goals, and feedback you provided. While no matchmaking service can guarantee chemistry or the outcome of any introduction, each match is selected in good faith using the information available at the time.
We also take client safety very seriously. When concerns were brought to our attention regarding an introduction, they were documented and addressed appropriately. While we conduct background screenings as part of our process, we cannot predict or control an individual's behavior after an introduction has been made.
Regarding your refund request, the terms of your membership agreement, including the cancellation and refund policy, were reviewed and acknowledged at the time of enrollment. While we understand your disappointment, we remain confident that our team acted professionally and in accordance with the membership agreement.
We appreciate your feedback and sincerely wish you the very best moving forward.
SG
Steve G.
Worried about what she did with my information
I would like to know what that lady did with my personal information? When I told I wasn't going to pay that much for their service she took my with my information and threw it in the bottom right hand drawer of her desk and crossed her arms and told me to think about it. I am worried about what she has done with my information? I sent a message to this company about a week ago. Haven't gotten a reply.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 29, 2026
Steve, thank you for sharing your concerns. We're sorry to hear that your experience left you with these impressions.
We take the privacy and security of personal information very seriously. For individuals who choose not to enroll in our services, any paperwork containing personal information is securely destroyed and disposed of in accordance with our internal procedures. Your information is not retained for marketing purposes or used beyond your initial inquiry.
We wish you the best moving forward.
AS
Andrea S.
It’s all about money, deception and coercion
Do not do businesses with this company there is nothing honest about them. This company WILL swindle you out of your money and lie and tell you whatever to get you to trust them. They have a recruiter who persuades you to go in. These people will not take no for an answer and keep pushing.. they ask you how much you make and create a "special discount pricing" only for today and push to get as much money from you. When you say no, they offer a cheaper "special pricing" and tell you only for today through coercion, manipulation and pressure you into purchasing. Typical high-pressure sales tactics. You believe everything they've told you about the program and they make it seem like every client chooses from these packages because if other clients are investing, that means they're as serious about the program as you are.. so you think. They never tell you're signing a contract. They tell you sign here initial here by this point you trust everything they're saying, but they're being very deceptive because every time they tell you something, they never look you in the eye. They make you pay absorbs amount of money and they recruit people for free and match them up with you. Even when you ask, they lie to you about your Match paying and have even changed documents on your preferences just to match their narrative. The company representative Chase Overstreet is very rude and takes what you say out of context and when you give feedback you're called a liar. He openly admitted the company does not care if you read their contract or not (which they purposely have you unknowingly sign). There's no way for you to find out any of this UNLESS you file complaints, fight back for your money or take them to court. That's when they openly admit everything they hid from you in regards to the matches not paying "promotions" while they charge you or give you "special pricing". The best thing you can do file multiple complaints to the state attorney, FDACS, etc. They say they've been around for 25 plus years but has only been actively registered for 4 years.. you can't believe anything they tell you... all they care about is your money and how much they can get out of you..
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 29, 2026
Andrea, we are sorry to hear that you remain dissatisfied with your experience. However, we respectfully disagree with many of the statements made in your review.
Our consultation process is designed to provide prospective clients with detailed information about our services, pricing, membership options, and the membership agreement before any enrollment decision is made. Clients are under no obligation to enroll and are encouraged to review the agreement and ask any questions they may have before signing.
We would also like to clarify that not every individual we introduce is a paying client. Some participants are complimentary members who have been selected because we believe they may be a strong match for one of our paying clients. This allows us to expand the pool of compatible introductions and create more opportunities for successful matches.
Additionally, we categorically deny the allegation that client documents were altered or that information was intentionally misrepresented. Our records reflect that your preferences and feedback were documented throughout your membership and that introductions were made based on those preferences, mutual compatibility, and availability.
Your concerns have already been fully addressed through the legal process, which concluded in the Company's favor. Throughout that process, we remained willing to continue providing the matchmaking services outlined in your membership agreement. However, you requested that we no longer contact you, and we have honored that request.
While we regret that your experience did not meet your expectations, we remain confident in the integrity of our process and wish you the very best moving forward.
JA
Jacqueline A.
This is a scam
This is a scam. Filled out all the info and next thing I know I’m getting calls about loans from different numbers. After I block report spam and delete, I get called by a new number. Filling out their form is the only connection to the spam calls about loans. No one ever called or emailed me from The Matchmaking Company.
Sad too because I don’t know how Trust Pilot missed this.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 26, 2026
Jacqueline, thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear about your experience.
We are not aware of any connection between your inquiry with The Matchmaking Company and the loan solicitation calls you described. We do not sell or share personal information with third parties for unrelated marketing purposes, and we have no affiliation with those calls.
The Matchmaking Company has more than 40 physical office locations across the country and has helped thousands of clients through our personalized matchmaking services. We take our clients' privacy and trust very seriously.
If there was an issue with your inquiry, we would welcome the opportunity to investigate it. We would also be happy to schedule a consultation so you can learn more about our process and determine whether our service is the right fit for you.
Thank you for bringing your concerns to our attention.
AM
Ariane M.
If your idea of matchmaking is filling…
If your idea of matchmaking is filling out questionnaires similar to online dating profiles, paying premium prices, and then leaving the rest to strangers, this may be the service for you.
While successful matchmaking requires both expertise and a genuine effort to understand clients, my experience left me questioning whether either was consistently present. From my first match, I openly communicated my concerns, particularly regarding what was promised during the "sales" process. While engaging and persuasive, I never felt truly heard. The same pattern continued with the two matchmakers assigned to me.
I am still awaiting a call from Elizabeth that was promised in February, and Isabella has been excellent at saying, "I'll connect with you next week." Unfortunately, those follow-ups rarely materialized. It has now been over a week since I requested contact information for a supervisor or complaints department. Historically, whenever I raised concerns, one of the matchmakers would reach out, but meaningful consideration of my feedback never seemed to follow.
At times, it felt as though my stated preferences were used as a guide for what not to match me with. When I expressed concerns, I often felt positioned as the difficult client rather than a paying customer seeking the service I purchased.
To keep things light, my friends have certainly enjoyed hearing about what became an unexpectedly entertaining dating adventure.
Match #1, "The Cowardly Lion," communicated almost entirely in vague generalities and somehow managed to avoid answering, and did while speaking in plurals. Still living at home?
Match #2, "The Tin Man," did not have a vehicle, stood me up twice, and eventually attended a free event I was hosting after borrowing Auntie Ann's car. He later invited me to my own church.
Match #3, "The Scarecrow," was the most concerning. Although background checks were reportedly completed, he actively participated in one of the two deal-breaker activities I had clearly identified as non-negotiable. Combined with a volatile temper, the experience left me feeling both drained and uncomfortable.
Of course, dating involves getting to know people and discovering compatibility. No matchmaker can predict chemistry. However, many people invest in professional matchmaking services to increase the likelihood of meeting individuals who share similar values, goals, and relationship intentions. That foundational level of compatibility should not feel optional.
I understand that life circumstances vary. Living with parents, returning to school at 45, or focusing on debt repayment can all be admirable choices. What is less attractive is using those circumstances to explain why someone believes they cannot meet a partner's expectations. That's a personal insecurity to address, not a compatibility issue for someone else to carry.
I recognize that matchmakers cannot know every detail about every client they introduce. However, none of the matches I received remotely resembled what I communicated I was seeking. Friends and family who know me well were consistently surprised by how poorly aligned these introductions were.
Had I encountered these individuals on a dating app, most would have received an immediate left swipe. Instead, I paid a significant amount of money for a service that promised personalized matchmaking and delivered experiences that felt random at best and concerning at worst.
At the end of this journey, I am left with a smaller bank account, diminished enthusiasm for dating, and a collection of stories that sound more like a dating-themed fairy tale gone wrong than a premium matchmaking experience. Update: After posting my review, I was asked by the company to remove it. Since 6/25, I have yet to hear from upper management. According to Isabella, they are "very busy," but somehow had time to reach out when the purpose of the call was to present another match and encourage me to take down my review. She again said her famous, next week line.
As she stated, my review may be deterring my match from finding me. Oh no!! Respectfully, this is not a desperate plea to find a man. This is a customer service issue, and if that was not clear from my original review, I am happy to clarify.
I have accepted the matches provided. I understand that matchmaking involves trial and error and that allowing someone else to help find a connection comes with uncertainty. I never expected perfection or a guaranteed relationship. What I did expect was communication, honesty, and follow-through from the company I invested in.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 25, 2026
Ariane, thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your experience has not met your expectations.
We understand that investing in a personalized matchmaking service comes with high expectations. While no matchmaking service can guarantee chemistry or the outcome of any introduction, we select each match based on a variety of compatibility factors, including preferences, relationship goals, values, lifestyle, mutual interest, and availability.
We also regret that you felt communication could have been more consistent. That is not the experience we strive to provide, and we appreciate your feedback regarding your interactions with our team.
Regarding your concerns about compatibility, we respectfully disagree that the introductions were made without consideration. Each introduction was presented in good faith based on the information available at the time, and client feedback is an essential part of refining future matches.
Your membership remains active, and you still have introductions remaining in your program. We would welcome the opportunity to move forward positively, and a member of our team will be reaching out to discuss your concerns and continue working toward finding a meaningful connection.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to continuing your journey with you.Ariane, thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your experience has not met your expectations.
We understand that investing in a personalized matchmaking service comes with high expectations. While no matchmaking service can guarantee chemistry or the outcome of any introduction, we select each match based on a variety of compatibility factors, including preferences, relationship goals, values, lifestyle, mutual interest, and availability.
We also regret that you felt communication could have been more consistent. That is not the experience we strive to provide, and we appreciate your feedback regarding your interactions with our team.
Regarding your concerns about compatibility, we respectfully disagree that the introductions were made without consideration. Each introduction was presented in good faith based on the information available at the time, and client feedback is an essential part of refining future matches.
Your membership remains active, and you still have introductions remaining in your program. We would welcome the opportunity to move forward positively, and a member of our team will be reaching out to discuss your concerns and continue working toward finding a meaningful connection.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to continuing your journey with you.
CH
Christa H.
Costly mistake
The interview sell was great. The reality was different. The matchmaker doesn’t respond. The matches so far have been way off, don’t meet criteria at all. You can do better on free apps than this very costly farce.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJun 19, 2026
Christa, thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that your experience has not met your expectations.
Matchmaking is a highly personalized and feedback-driven process, and while not every introduction results in a connection, each is selected based on compatibility factors, preferences, and the information available at the time.
We regret that you felt communication could have been stronger and that the introductions did not align with your expectations. Your feedback is important to us, and a member of our team will be reaching out to you directly to discuss your concerns and work together on a positive path forward.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to continuing the process with you.