Jerky Boys Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of jerkyboys.com

Jerky Boys Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of jerkyboys.com

Jerky Boys reviews

Showing 4 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters

Rodney
Aug 10, 2026
Average product demanding premium purchasing experience.
Order and delivery was very smooth, but given how much talk surrounded this original recipe, I'll be honest and say that it doesn't rise above the competition and impress me. I am more than content with the meat snack selections at my local grocery store and wont be bothered to pay a premium price or wait for an order to be shipped.
Response from Jerky BoysAug 10, 2026
Thanks for giving us a try and for sharing your honest feedback. We know taste is subjective, and we respect that. Our focus has always been on making homemade-style jerky using whole muscle beef, hand-cut slices, and our family’s generations-old recipe. It’s a different style of jerky, and while it wasn’t the right fit for you, we truly appreciate you giving Jerky Boys a chance and taking the time to share your experience.
Report
Dude in O.
Jul 31, 2026
Extremely tough to chew
Seems like a well ran company and the jerky has a great flavor but it's like gnawing on dry rotted leather. I would try it again if they came out with a soft version.
Response from Jerky BoysAug 4, 2026
Thank you so much for giving us a try, and we’re sorry to hear it wasn’t the texture you were looking for. We really appreciate your honest feedback. Our jerky is made from whole-muscle, hand-cut prime beef using a family recipe, so it’s intentionally a drier, more traditional style than the softer, formed jerky many brands make today. We’re glad to hear you enjoyed the flavor, and we truly appreciate you giving our small family business a chance.
Report
Wayne
Mar 10, 2026
The bags are VERY small
The bags are VERY small, I will be canceling my subscription. WAY over priced for the quality & quantity.
Response from Jerky BoysMar 10, 2026
Hi Marvin, thanks for giving Jerky Boys a try and for sharing your feedback. Our jerky is made from whole cuts of prime beef and hand-cut, which results in smaller bags compared to many mass-produced brands that use processed meat or fillers. We focus on quality and real beef over quantity. We’re sorry to hear it wasn’t the right fit for you, but we appreciate you giving it a shot and hope you might give us another try in the future.
Report
Jack D.
Oct 14, 2025
This was my first order
This was my first order. The jerky was so hard that I couldn’t bite through it. I buy different kinds of jerky all the time and the flavor wasn’t near the top of the ones that I’ve tried. Maybe offer some other options for flavors. I always buy original flavors but I might be willing to try your product again if you produce something new.
Response from Jerky BoysOct 30, 2025
Hey Jack! We take pride in crafting authentic, thick-cut beef jerky with a firm, traditional texture. Not the soft, mass-produced style you’ll find elsewhere. We understand that preference varies, and we respect your feedback. We’re always exploring new flavor options, but our original recipe remains true to our roots. We appreciate you trying Jerky Boys.
Report