Gage Diamonds is Chicago's premier retailer of engagement rings, wedding bands, fine jewelry, and designer watches. Buy now and pay over 12-24 months with 100% no-credit-needed financing through LendFirm. Apply today and get approved in less than 24 hours. All you need is a valid bank account in good standing and direct deposit.
Gage Diamonds (gagediamonds.com) has 438 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Also known as
gagediamonds.com
Website
gagediamonds.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Location
Chicago, Illinois
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 13% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: June 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Communication was lacking! I ordered the ring and decided to change the stone shape. Sent an email asking if this was possible, after 3 days of no response I called to verify that this could be done. The lady said yes somebody would reply to the email I sent with the cost and delay to make the change. 3 days later I got an email saying the change could be made but it would delay the delivery a few days. I was fine with the delay and responded to proceed with the change. Fast forward 2 weeks, I received the ring but the stone was never changed. The ring does seem like decent quality and I will just stick with the original stone shape that was sent. Communication is definitely an issue for this company though unfortunately.
CB
Chozan B.
Its been 21 days since I placed my…
Its been 21 days since I placed my order. I was told it would only take approximately 2 weeks for my order to be completed. The company has done minimal communication to keep me updated on my order status. The status date still shows December 27th, the date of my original order, on my Gage Diamonds account. No update since then.
Your company needs to be more proactive in updating the status of orders, especially since thousands of dollars was spent on this order.
Response from Gage DiamondsJan 18, 2023
Hi Chozan, as stated on our website and all order confirmation emails, all orders take 10-15 business days to complete, which are Mondays-Fridays, not including holidays. Since you placed your order on December 27th, we've had New Year's Day (recognized on January 2) and Martin Luther King Jr. Day on January 16th. Today marks the 14th business day since your order was placed, however LendFirm notified us on Janaury 6th, midway through production, that they were unable to process a first payment due to incorrect banking information provided on your account, thus pausing production on your item. After 5-business days of an item paused in production, the order is canceled. We only received confirmation from LendFirm that they received updated banking information on January 13th, which is when production restarted on the item, and another 10-15 businesss days. We also have no record of you reaching out to us at any point, but we do have record of you opening our email updating you on the status of your order on January 10th. Please feel free to reach out to us at [email protected] if you have any further questions.
JH
Justin H.
Poor Customer Service
Item was slated to ship on a certain date. Of course it didn't. Called in to have faster shipping since I wouldn't be home the following week because of a traveling work assignment. Was told it would cost $150 for overnight. Would not wave the shipping fee even though they dropped the ball. I understand things happen but I definitely have no control over their production time.
DA
David
Misquoted arrival time
Ordered my wife a wedding band upgrade on December 5th I was told I would have it before Christmas. I called on the 20th because I was worried that it hadn’t shipped yet I was told that it takes 4-6 weeks and that they are sorry about the misquoted time any other time I would have been ok with it but my wife still doesn’t have her ring and I haven’t heard anything back from gage yet I’m not just a angry customer I actually purchased three other expensive items totaling over 8k and they came just fine within the quoted time I’m not sure what’s going on there I guess I have to continue to wait but I hope it will be here before next year the surprise is already ruined not a good experience at all
Response from Gage DiamondsDec 28, 2021
Hi David, I am so sorry to hear you have been disappointed with the customer service and communication provided throughout your Gage Diamonds journey. I have reviewed your order details and it appears that the item you've mentioned is special order, and will take 4-6 weeks to produce, as stated on our website. I apologize if you were told this item would arrive sooner. Please feel free to email mashbrook[at]gagediamonds.com with additional details on your experience so we can rectify the situation for you.
JA
John A.
I have been trying for days to get a…
I have been trying for days to get a simple answer and keep being told i will check and get back to you. 3 days and 3 calls later NOTHING!
Your reply has nothing to do with what my customer service issues were about!! But thanks for a reply ON HERE!
Response from Gage DiamondsDec 28, 2021
Hi John, I am so sorry to hear you are unsatisfied with the customer service provided. I have reviewed your order details and it shows that you placed an order for a custom design on December 14th. As stated on our site and order confirmation emails, all orders take 10-15 business days (meaning Monday - Friday, not including holidays.) Your order is still on track to be shipped and delivered on schedule. Unlike big-box jewelers who mass produce their jewelry, each piece at Gage Duanibds is made-to-order and created with the utmost attention to detail and craftsmanship. Every piece is then meticulously examined by quality control to ensure your piece meets our exceptionally high standards, which is why the production time is 10-15 business days.
LC
Lendfirm C.
There financing company is horrible.
There financing company is horrible.
Response from Gage DiamondsDec 28, 2021
Thank you for sharing your experience. We are so sorry to hear you are dissatisfied with our financing partner. Please feel free to email mashbrook[at]gagediamonds.com with additional details on your experience so we can rectify the situation for you.
LA
Larry
I have not recieve my items
I have not recieve my items
BL
Blake
Not as helpful as they were the first…
Not as helpful as they were the first time I ordered. It was hard to find the matching wedding ring from the original engagement ring and the price went up 200 dollars in a months time. I had to order from here to get the matching ring it wasn’t available anywhere else so I was forced to use gage. unless they give me a price break on the 200 dollar up charge then I’ll probably do by other ring buying elsewhere for now on
Response from Gage DiamondsSep 27, 2021
Hi Blake, unfortunately, due to vendor price increases, we were forced to increase prices on certain products.