Sharon H.
First of all there is no customer…
First of all there is no customer service by phone .I WANTED TO CHANGE MY Boat because I realized there was no first mate and we wanted to go deep sea fishing That’s mainly why we came to islamorada. Finally figured out how to call. Frustrating. Then we arrived and they said once we were onboard if we wanted to go offshore another 12 mi it was another 500 dollars for another 2 hours. Basically we went out to a spot and stayed in the same place the whole time. The singing real was a big boat but wouldn’t use its gas to do what we asked. When we got back about a few slips away another boat went 4 hours and caught tuna mahi mahi and more. The customer told me she signed up for 4 hours : we did catch yellowtale and learned a little bit about inshore fishing but this was a setup for naive people. Obviously we were upset . Later they told us they had to pay the fishing booker a lot of money. They seemed nice but it was a sham. The website itself is made to make money and make every captain pay and charge more. Never before has this been the case when we booked directly down here. Not again. One other thing. Normal tipping is 20%. They asked me for 25% like it was part of the price. People who haven’t deep sea fished before wouldn’t know this. Beware of being scammed. By the way in total this cost1350 for simple inshore fishing.
Response from FishingBookerSep 3, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. We’re sorry the trip did not match what you were expecting, but we would like to clarify a few points. The 4-hour trip booked was specifically advertised for inshore, reef and slightly offshore fishing, including reef fishing and light tackle. The offshore fishing and species mentioned in this review are advertised on the captain’s longer trips. The additional $500 discussed was the advertised price difference between the 4-hour trip booked and the 6-hour trip. You can confirm that on the captain's lisitng. While we understand it can be disappointing to see another boat return with a different catch, each charter and trip has its own itinerary and inclusions. We always recommend reviewing the specific trip description when booking, particularly when there are certain species or a specific type of fishing you’re looking for. We also want to clarify that phone support is available, and we do have a phone conversation with you on file. The captain’s direct number is provided in the confirmation email, and our contact numbers are available on our Contact Us page. The 25% gratuity is mentioned on the listing as well, but it is suggested, not mandatory. We’re sorry there was a misunderstanding about what was included in the trip. We’re always happy to help before booking to make sure the charter selected is the right fit for the experience you’re looking for.




