everlyrings.comReviews of everlyrings.com

Id give this place zero stars if I could. I actually worked with them in person because I’m local. The ring quality is WORSE than SHEIN and Amazon rings that I’ve purchased. It looks gorgeous at first, but within ONE WEEK even with all the “gold-plating rules” being followed, the plating will wear off. I took my first ring in within a week because I thought this would CLEARLY be under the “warranty,” but of course it wasn’t. They did give me a new ring and said they could never do that again. Well, no surprise to anyone, the second ring’s plating started wearing off within a week as well. Absolutely ABYSMAL. This company should absolutely be ashamed of itself for SCAMMING people the way they do.

Horrible customer service. I received a size 4 ring (actual size 3.5). They argued that it was 3.75. whatever. I ordered and paid for a size 4. The delay in their responses knocked me out of the return window. Never heard from them again despite multiple emails, hence no resolution. Absolutely one of the worst customer experiences ever in my life. They deserved minus 5 stars.

As a repeat customer, I expected better. After not one, but TWO defective rings, I was offered a replacement—at a cost of $19.99—despite the issue occurring just outside the 30-day warranty. This policy feels intentionally designed to generate revenue from predictable product failures. It’s disappointing and, frankly, misleading. I reviewed the warranty before purchase, but the structure suggests Everly anticipates defects and profits from them. As a businesswoman, I understand the strategy—but I don’t support it. I won’t be purchasing from Everly again, and I’ll advise others to do the same.

If I could give no stars I would. No communication after I purchased when I had queries about the length of shipping. When it arrived a diamond is missing, ring was of very bad quality and I emailed a photo and got NO REPLY AGAIN. This is robbing people’s money.

Rings are complete junk. Rhinestones fall out with a few days on 3 of the rings I purchased. It was replaced however same thing happened after 30 days which is outside the return policy. The rhinestones should not be falling out at all.

I purchased multiple rings from everly a few months ago and loved them. gorgeous styles. however, within only a few months, almost all of the stones have fallen out. i would never recommend this company to anyone. for the price you're paying, it's not worth it. I've purchased better quality rings on amazon for a fraction of the price

I would give zero stars. Their quality is TRASH as is the service. Amazon has better quality and service. After wearing 1 time 9 stones fell out and they won't even offer credit. Mind you this order just arrived a day ago!

I never contacted anyone, but my ring never looked like the ones in the pictures and videos. It was completely cloudy after a month and the wear wasn’t even daily. I’ve compared it to my sister’s CZ off of Amazon for $18 and hers sparkles WAY more. Buyer beware!