Sky
I love the concept but...
I love the concept. But the body wash and shampoo weren't very fragrant. Especially in the shower. The smell was gone in seconds and it smelled a bit off while in use. The shampoo bar I will still use in a pinch, it smells lovely in the package, suds nicely and while my hair is scent free out of the shower, it does leave my bangs a nice texture for styling which is a must in my shower routine. It'd also be nice if it came in paper. A lot of people buy shampoo bars to eliminate plastic waste. I'm disappointed in the products overall. For 20 dollars the body wash should be much more potent in scent. 20 dollars is a lot for the amount of product you get and how it performs. I understand it's hand made. I'd be willing to pay that price for hand made things and support a small business, but scent is a huge things for me. She has a huge selection. Don't let my 2 star review of the toasted marshmallow scent stop you from checking out her other things, there are so many products and dozens of scents.
Response from Eclectic LadyOct 16, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share such a thoughtful and detailed review. While we're disappointed that our Toasted Marshmallow body wash and shampoo bar didn't fully meet your expectations, we genuinely appreciate your honest feedback and your willingness to support a small, handmade business. We understand that fragrance strength and longevity are important, especially when scent is a major reason for choosing a product. Fragrance performance can vary between formulations, and we're sorry these products didn't deliver the experience you were hoping for. Your comments about the scent during use are particularly helpful, and we'll certainly take them into consideration as we continue evaluating our products. We're glad to hear that you enjoyed the shampoo bar's lather and the texture it leaves in your hair! We also appreciate your suggestion about paper packaging. Reducing unnecessary packaging waste is important, and feedback like yours helps us identify areas where we can improve. Most of all, thank you for recognizing our extensive fragrance selection and encouraging others to explore our products despite your experience. That kindness means a great deal to us. We truly appreciate your support, your honesty, and the opportunity to learn from your experience. 💜