We specialize in production of custom leather holsters, designed to fit everyday carry needs of any responsible gun owner. If you're looking for comfortable, safe, and enjoyable carry experience, Craft Holsters is a place to go to.
Craft Holsters (craftholsters.com) has 426 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.5 out of 5.
Also known as
craftholsters.com
Website
craftholsters.com
Category
Fabric & Stationery
Location
Tualatin, Oregon
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 36% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I originally thought the holster was wrong but after contacting the company and using the denatured alcohol, it worked great. I was surprised how quickly their response was. I would do business with them again in a heartbeat. You can clearly see they stand behind their products and want you to be happy. It feels like a nice, quality product.
AP
A P.
First custom leather purchase. Wonderful.
I had a custom left handed shoulder holster made. The product is beautiful craftsmanship. I never depart from home without it. I will order again in the future from this company. I received my very near to the estimated time frame. It was only delayed because I used the fed ex option. I enjoyed tracking the product as it made its way around the world. Thank you again for such a wonderful personalized item. You helped me now I help you.
JK
John K.
Excellent quality and fit.
Received my IWB holster and very pleased with the quality and fit of this holster. Searched a long time to find the perfect holster for my Colt King Cobra 3" revolver and this was a perfect fit. Had to massage the strap but no need to do anything else. Delivery within a week using the economy shipping. Liked the quality so much I just placed an order for their belt and speedloader. Highly recommend.
MU
Mullefar01
Refund problems.
Wanted refund after order was delayed.
Asked for my money back 3 times, with no results.
Had to escalate refund through Paypal before i could get my money back.
Response from Craft HolstersMar 10, 2023
Hey sir!
I'm very sorry your new holster didn't match your expectations.
Also, I apologize for the wait time as far as your refund goes, but I'm glad to hear you got your money back in the end.
Thanks for your patience & understanding and I hope you'll find a reason to come back to us if you need a holster in the future.
Regards, Al from Craft Holsters
RT
Ray T.
Purchased and received a shoulder…
Purchased and received a shoulder holster with magazine carrier. Upon receipt I discovered that the retention strap was way too short and not even close to being able to be snapped closed to secure the firearm.
As requested I filled out a claim form, sent numerous pics of the gun, the gun in the holster and the issue from different angles. In response Craft Holsters sent me instructions on how to force stretch the strap. After numerous attempts over several days were unsuccessful I reported to them that their remedy was not working and in reply they handed it off to a different customer service rep who requested the same pics and info I had already sent.
I responded to that email and have heard nothing since.
Response from Craft HolstersFeb 24, 2023
Hey sir!
Thanks for your review. I'm very sorry for the entire situation, as I've already said on our Facebook page.
Your issue is currently being resolved and all I'm asking for is a bit of patience.
Please, understand that the holster you ordered from us is made for us by our co-producer, who have their own rules when it comes to claims, which we need to accept.
My colleagues will definitely come back to you as soon as they know how to resolve your problem. Please, make sure you check your spam folder as their emails sometimes end there. They're mailing from "[email protected]".
Regards, Al from Craft Holsters
SS
Steven S.
Very disappointed.
I got my Craft holster today and I’m very disappointed. This is not what I, or anyone who knows holsters, would call a custom holster. It is not well fitted to the gun and doesn’t fit tight enough to feel secure. A real custom, fitted holster is molded to every grove of the gun and is very tight when new to allow for break-in; this one is loose and is more of a generic holster which would fit any gun of similar size. I’m afraid with use it will not hold the gun securely.
Response from Craft HolstersJan 26, 2023
Hey sir!
I'm very sorry to hear you're dissatisfied with your new holster. Please, contact my colleagues at "[email protected]" or let me know what your order number was, so that I can prompt my colleagues into reaching out to you asap.
Regards, Al from Craft Holsters
GC
Gary C.
Unhappy
PREFACE: This is a nylon holster, not a leather holster. There would be no leather type of brake in on this style!
Holster is to small for the gun and light. It took everything I had to get the pistol in the holster. It pushed the slide back an inch while trying to insert pistol (I am surprised the round in the chamber didn't get ejected, that would have meant I would have had to cut the holster up to get it out, since it would have jammed the pistol in the holster). Re-tension is a little piece of Velcro that goes over the grip, that defeats the grip safety on my Springfield XD. Trying to remove the pistol back out of the holster is a feat in it self. I thought I was going to rip my Olight flashlight/laser off the gun. If I was to use this holster and had to get the gun out for an event. I would be talking to my Lord and Savior Jesus Christ long before that would have ever happen!!
I have read negatives on customer service since I made the purchase, so I can not see relief in sight.
Also I had another charge after I paid for the item. They are located in ' THE HOLSTERS COMPANY, ANDREJA KMETA 17 BANSKA STIAVNICA, SLOVAKIA, 96901' ( Eastern Europe ), so there was a $3.09 money transfer fee.
If I wanted them to fix the problem, I have read that I would have to pay to send it back to them.
I kick my self in the back side for not researching the company more, and finding out they were on the other side of the world.
SO,,,, I am out about $110.00, and all I have a dust collector!!!
Response from Craft HolstersDec 5, 2022
Hey sir!
I'm very sorry you've got no use for the holster. Please, email my colleagues at "[email protected]" in case you wish to return it (if you haven't done so earlier).
Regards, Al from Craft Holsters
DW
david W.
I have two craft holsters
I have two craft holsters, a shoulder and an IWB, everything is great except for one thing, the metal clip for the IWB is way too immobile, it is a really hard job to clip it over your belt because the metal has zero give in it, if you have to take it off do not expect to be able to put in only again too quickly or inconspicuously. As due to my work I have to remove the holster when entering certain places, I can not use the IWB, so disappointing as the workmanship is so good otherwise.
Response from Craft HolstersDec 5, 2022
Hey sir!
I'm sorry to hear about the issue with your IWB holster :(
Also, sorry for only reacting to your review now, but I haven't noticed it earlier.
In case you don't have any use for the holster, please, contact my colleagues at "[email protected]" and they'll let you know how to go about returning it.
Regards, Al from Craft Holsters