We believe in bedding that is as soft on the earth as it is on your bed. The old-fashioned textile industry has spent years consuming tons of water, harming animals, and polluting our oceans and air with toxic chemicals. We’re here with a fresh start: home goods that are earth-friendly, skin-friendly, cruelty-free, and super-soft. Because we think a comfy night’s sleep is even comfier when it doesn’t harm the environment.
Buffy (buffy.co) has 291 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Also known as
buffy.co
Website
buffy.co
Category
Furniture Stores
Location
New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 63% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I ordered two comforters from this company and they tell you it will ship on a certain date. It does not. They then blame the shipping company that it’s their fault. They tell me they started another order and it’s the same run around. I’ve tried canceling my order, but, of course, they won’t let you do that. Do not order anything from this scam company. They are the worst company I have ever experienced.
Response from BuffyOct 21, 2026
Hi there,
We’re very sorry for the frustration and inconvenience you experienced with your order. We understand how disappointing it is to experience repeated delays, especially when you’re looking forward to receiving your items.
After reviewing your support history, I can see that your original order was unfortunately misplaced by the carrier. While this is a rare occurrence, we understand that it doesn’t make the experience any less frustrating. We carefully select our shipping partners to provide reliable and timely delivery, and we sincerely apologize that your experience fell short of those expectations.
I can also confirm that your replacement order was successfully delivered on October 20.
We appreciate your patience throughout this process and are sorry for the trouble this caused.
Sleep well,
The Buffy Team
AT
Aubrey T.
Very Disappointed
I received the Breeze sheets set for Christmas and was very optimistic regarding the quality of the Buffy sheets due to numerous outstanding reviews. However, after about 6 months I noticed a tear in the fabric. I would love nothing more than to rave about the wonderful sheets, but due to them tearing my opinion has been swayed. I cannot justify the price of the sheets for the poor quality. I was quite disappointed with how the sheets held up. While they were great when we first received them, the fabric did not hold up.
Response from BuffyOct 19, 2026
Hello Aubrey,
We’re sorry to hear your sheets haven’t held up to the quality we expect from our products. Please reach out to us at [email protected] with your original order number so our team can review the issue and evaluate your eligibility for a warranty replacement. We’d appreciate the opportunity to look into this for you.
Sleep well,
The Buffy Team
MW
M W.
Buyer beware
I stand by this review. I only received a telephone number to call by posting this review. I had already emailed Melissa at hellobuffy.com. I called Buffy and left a message. Melissa called me back and encouraged me to remove the disputed charge I placed. Melissa stated Buffy cannot refund or cancel the order if a dispute or chargeback has been initiated. That information is false. Buffy is choosing not to refund the order. The merchandise was lost in transit. Buffy has been extremely slow to respond. I have done all the leg work by calling and explaining the situation with the intention of resolving the issue, which is more effort than Buffy has made.
Buyer beware. No customer service. You can’t call the company. They only communicate with customers via text or email. I bought a wedding gift from Buffy via a wedding registry link in August. The merchandise was not shipped for 6 weeks. I received an email about tracking the order. The link was expired. When I submitted/received a request for a renewed link, it was also expired. The merchandise was apparently “lost in transit” according to Buffy. I received a text message stating they would reach out to me via email. No one reached out. 3 days later, I am copied on an email sent to the gift recipient that they need to reach out to their bank! No email to me. I am the one who made the purchase. AI reports Buffy responds to negative reviews on this site. It also repots that there are many complaints about the lack of customer service and problems with refunds. And since there is no phone number, they certainly don’t want to talk to you. With so many other shopping options available, take advantage of working with a reputable company, not Buffy.
Response from BuffyOct 16, 2026
Hello,
We’re very sorry for the issues you and the gift recipient experienced with your registry order. This is not the experience we want for either of you, and we understand your frustration with the shipping delays and communication.
We’d appreciate the opportunity to look into what happened and make this right. Unfortunately, we’re unable to locate your order or support history based on the information provided in your review. Please contact our team by phone at 1-833-698-5431 or by email at [email protected] so we can investigate further and assist you directly.
Best,
The Buffy Team
MA
Marlene
HORRIBLE!!
HORRIBLE!!! I ordered the Breeze sheets. I received a bottle of cheap perfume. Customer service was talking to me but after I managed to send them the pictures, they have ghosted me. I will be filling a claim with my bank and reporting them. They charged me for the sheets that I still have not received. This is a huge scam. Don't fall for it!!! These sheets were advertised on my EAP app through my company. They will be getting a report as well. I am disgusted.
Response from BuffySep 30, 2026
Hello,
We are so sorry that you received an incorrect item from another brand through our fulfillment center. We completely understand how frustrating this experience must have been.
I reviewed your ticket with our Customer Service team and can confirm that a replacement for your Breeze Sheets has been arranged. Our team will follow up with the tracking information shortly.
We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience and appreciate your patience while we worked to get this resolved. We hope you love your Breeze Sheets once they arrive.
Sleep well,
The Buffy Team
KH
Kyle H.
Fitted sheet tore in under 20 months — customer service only offered a discount on a replacement set
I bought the Breeze Sheet Set expecting durability to match the premium price. Instead, after just 20 months of normal use, the fitted sheet developed a hole and wore through.
When I contacted support, I was told it falls outside their 1-year warranty. Because they don’t sell or replace individual fitted sheets, their only solution was a 35% discount coupon toward buying another set.
Paying over $110 out-of-pocket to replace a prematurely worn product means spending over $400 on bedding across 5 years. That makes no sense. A quality brand should stand behind its materials rather than using product failures to drive more sales. I won't be buying from Buffy again.
Response from BuffyAug 24, 2026
Hello,
We’re sorry to hear about the experience you had with your fitted sheet. We understand how frustrating it is to have a sheet develop a hole after just 20 months of use.
We also want to clarify that we do sell individual fitted sheets, so we’re sorry for any confusion you may have received from our team. We appreciate you sharing your feedback, and we’ll make sure it’s passed along.
We hope you’ll consider giving Buffy another try in the future. We’d love the opportunity to provide you with a better experience.
Best,
The Buffy Team
TI
Tamara I.
Horrible quality
The breeze sheet set is absolute horrible quality. Especially for the price. What a rip off. It has had rough little pills on it since the beginning. Interesting how I can’t make a review of it on their website.
Response from BuffyJun 29, 2026
Hello,
We’re very sorry to hear this has been your experience. Pilling is certainly not what we want our customers to experience, and we’d like the opportunity to make this right. Please reach out to us at [email protected] with your order details and photos of the sheets, and our Customer Experience team will be happy to look into this and assist you with a resolution.
Best,
The Buffy Team
MA
Matt
Do not buy from this company.
Do not buy from this company.
I received defective merchandise and immediately contacted customer service with detailed photos documenting the issues. What followed was weeks of delays, repeated requests for documentation, shifting explanations, and a complete refusal to take responsibility for the condition of the products that were delivered.
The most frustrating part was not the defective products themselves. Manufacturing issues happen. The problem was that at every stage of the process, the company seemed focused on shifting blame rather than standing behind its products and making the situation right.
I was repeatedly asked to provide additional evidence, purchase my own shipping materials, package oversized items myself, and spend my own time arranging the return of products that arrived defective. Even after complying with every request and providing extensive documentation, the company continued to dispute issues, question evidence, and create additional hurdles rather than simply resolving the matter.
Instead of accepting responsibility, the company consistently looked for ways to explain away the defects, shift the burden onto the customer, or avoid accountability for the situation.
A reputable company stands behind its products when something goes wrong. Based on my experience, this company did the opposite.
There are many other companies selling similar products. I strongly recommend purchasing from one of them instead.
Response from BuffyJun 16, 2026
Hello,
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry to hear that you were dissatisfied with your experience.
We take reports of product issues seriously and thoroughly review all claims submitted to our team. Throughout this process, our goal was to gather the information necessary to evaluate the concerns raised and determine the appropriate resolution in accordance with our policies.
As part of that process, return labels were provided so the products could be returned and inspected. At this time, the items have not been received at our warehouse, and the return tracking information does not show that the packages have been shipped. Because we have not received the products back, we have been unable to complete our inspection or issue a refund.
We understand that returns can be inconvenient, particularly for larger items, but receiving the products is a necessary step in verifying reported defects and processing refunds fairly and consistently for all customers.
Should the items be successfully returned and received at our facility, we would be happy to continue the review and resolution process.
Sleep Well,
The Buffy Team
LC
Lauren C.
Dishonest company with fake advertising about trials and returns
They are not an honest company. They advertise a 7 night trial and "try before you buy". However that trial actually starts when you place the order, not when you receive it, which is 7 days later anyway.
They advertise 50 day returns but when I tried to get a return started they said I have to donate it to goodwill or similar and send a picture of the receipt.
Overall not in line with every other modern company that actually offers returns and you can initiate them online without so much back and forth. I had ordered two different colors to see in person and now I have to go through this to get $50 back for pillowcases.
Expensive and not worth it at all. My pillow and case is ok but not worth their difficult service.
Response from BuffyJun 16, 2026
Hello,
Thank you for sharing your experience. We’re sorry to hear that our return process did not meet your expectations.
We strive to be transparent about our policies and understand that there can sometimes be confusion around eligibility windows, trial periods, and return options. Our donation-based return program is designed to keep gently used bedding out of landfills while still providing customers with a refund, but we recognize that this process may not be as convenient as a traditional return for everyone.
We appreciate your feedback regarding the experience of comparing colors and navigating the return process. Input like yours helps us evaluate how we communicate our policies and where we can improve the customer experience.
While we’re glad to hear that the product itself met your needs, we’re sorry that the overall experience left you feeling disappointed. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to try our products and for taking the time to share your thoughts.
Sleep Well,
The Buffy Team