Ronald
Polite
Polite, professional, and knowledgeable staff. Always aims to please.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Thank you, Ronald. We truly appreciate your review.

Find the best jewelry selection, style, quality and service when you visit Ben Garelick. Offering eye catching diamond engagement rings and a fine jewelry selection, our experienced staff will help you find the perfect piece. Whether it's an engagement ring, an anniversary gift, a ‘push present’ for a new mom or just a gift for a special someone, we’ve got the perfect size, cut and color for every occasion. For over 60 years, Ben Garelick has helped thousands of clients make holidays, weddings, birthdays and anniversaries extra special.
Ben Garelick (bengarelick.com) has 52 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Huntington, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Brooklyn, New York
Excellent
52 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Ronald
Polite, professional, and knowledgeable staff. Always aims to please.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Thank you, Ronald. We truly appreciate your review.
Jason
My wife and I stopped in for the first time and was highly impressed with the selection and the staff. The product pricing was in-line with competitor stores, but had pieces that others don't carry. The laid-back environment made purchasing easier. I would absolutely recommend this jeweler to any of my friends, family and people looking for items.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Jason, your recommendation is the highest compliment. Thank you!
Shawn
We have been customers for twenty five years plus. We have always been treated with respect and value as customers. We would recommend this company to anyone.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Your review and your business are valued more than diamonds and gold! Thank you Shawn.
Jennifer
I looked at quite a few stores to find a diamond. The service at any of the other stores didn't compare to that of Ben Garelick. No pressure, plenty of information, understood my needs, and ultimately won my business. I will definitely return. I encourage you to check them out- especially over the big stores- you won't be disappointed. One other point to note- once I made a decision, they were insanely FAST getting my ring back to me!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
We usually don't appreciate being called insane, but in this case we really like it! Thank you Jennifer.
Customer
The store has amazing products and professional, courteous staff. Peter is incredible! He always helps me find exactly what I need and is very prompt at replying to my questions.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Thank you for such a nice review!
Donna P.
Ben Garelick offers quality jewelry along with superb customer service. They offer unique pieces and their staff is well educated. I often recommend this company to friends and associates.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Donna, thank you for your 5 star review! It is a pleasure to offer beautiful things to smart, stylish customers like you! We'll be sure to let everyone on staff of your lovely compliment!
Katie
I would recommend Ben Garelick to everyone! I have purchased jewelry there in the past and my boyfriend and I went ring shopping there recently! Their customer service is outstanding and their jewelry is top quality. They have a jeweler on site so if you need a ring sized or a repair made it never leaves their store front. Peter Jr. and his father (Peter Sr.) are always a pleasure and make you feel like family. I will never go anywhere else!!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Thank you for your 5 star review, Katie! We loved working with you and your boyfriend, and look forward to helping you find sparkling jewelry for many happy years to come!
Andrew
Peter made an otherwise intimidating situation extremely comfortable. I was given background on diamonds and settings and honest answers to questions I had about pricing. There was a slight mix-up with the diamond and setting and Peter handled it better than I could have imagined. He honored a price that we agreed upon during my first visit even though, because of the mix-up, the ring I was receiving was much more expensive. I am confident in saying that I would not have received that treatment had I gone elsewhere and had there been the same mix-up. I will absolutely, without reservation, recommend Ben Garelick to family and friends.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Andrew, we are so happy we could help make what can be an overwhelming experience comfortable and happy. Thank you for your great recommendation! It is truly appreciated.