As licensed Public Insurance Adjusters, we are experienced in negotiating claims with insurance companies. We have teamed up with Vehicle Value Experts for access to the best vehicle valuing tool available. Together, with the best knowledge and the best negotiating skills, we can ensure a fair settlement of your auto claim.
Auto Claim Specialists (autoclaimspecialists.com) has 381 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
Also known as
autoclaimspecialists.com
Website
autoclaimspecialists.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Fort Worth, Texas
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 100% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
My experience with Auto Claims Specialist, and James Byerly was exceptional. Not only was the outcome favorable, but when i initially called, i was a little hesitant and unsure of the whole process. They made it so very easy. They gave me a timeline and expectations of the Diminished Value claim. Everything they said and did was how it happened. They are a great company to deal with and James followed up and kept me in the loop during the whole process. I usually don't do testimonials but this was one time i did because they deserved to be praised for their great work and honesty.
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsNov 22, 2019
Dear Alex,
Thank You so much for taking time to issue us a review. We truly appreciate your business. I hope you never need us in the future. However, if the unfortunate arises please call.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
CG
Carol G.
Best Insurance Advocate for the Little Guy
A deer jumped in front of my paid- off Honda last fall and totaled my vehicle. I had never had a wreck or dealt with an insurance company before. I was busy with a sick parent and was advised to get a third party adjuster to help navigate the process and be my private advocate and representative. I had been a long-time customer of Farm Bureau. The insurance company quickly offered $6,600 ($2,000 less than the car was worth) for my property damage and pressured me to sign the car over to them immediately so they wouldn’t have to pay storage, which I did. They then dealt unfairly with me in giving me fair market value for my car. With Mr. McDorman’s help, on my behalf, he exercised my right to protest under my policy. After my personal adjuster wrote numerous letters, consulted lawyers, etc. and made a case for Bad Faith Practices and threatened legal action, the insurance company finally admitted wrongdoing and unnecessary delay and paid out over $15,000 for property damage and loss of use. Bottom line, don’t let these insurance companies push you around and devalue your property they owe you for. By law, there are provisions in your policy to help protect you! I highly recommend Robert McDorman to help you navigate the process. He only collects if he gets you more than the original offer, and his cut is more than fair. The man is a work horse and he took my problem personally!! He was always a phone call or text away from an update and he is incredibly knowledgeable about the business, the insurance adjuster community, and the insurance claims climate in Texas. He got me more than twice as much as the insurance company was going to pay!
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsNov 22, 2019
Dear Mr. Groves,
It was a pleasure working with you. We appreciate you taking time to issue us a review. Thank you for pointing out the insured has rights. We average a 29% increase from the carriers final settlement on Total Loss claims. I hope you never need us again. However, if the unfortunate arises please call.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
AN
Anna
It was a pleasure dealing with James…
It was a pleasure dealing with James Byerly at Auto Claims Specialists. I didn’t have to do anything, he took care of everything for me. He’s also very nice and quite entertaining, which helped make an awful experience with an uninsured motorist bearable! I hope I never need his services again, but if I do, I know who to call!
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsNov 22, 2019
Dear Anna,
Thank You for taking time to issue us a review. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
BM
Bill McRae Ford L.
Auto Claim Specialists did us a…
Auto Claim Specialists did us a fantastic job negotiating with the insurance company of an individual that ran into one of our new trucks while on a test drive. This was a very expensive 2019 Ford King Ranch F250 Crew Cab and the accident caused almost 15k dollars in damage to this new truck. Auto Claim Specialists contracted with me to aid in receiving a fair diminished value for the damage to this truck. They had me a settlement in a very timely manner and I could not be more pleased with the ease in working with them. I highly recommend them!
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsOct 23, 2019
Thank You Mr. McRae for taking time to issue us a review. We enjoyed working with you and your staff. I hope you never need us again. However, if the unfortunate comes along, please call us and we will be there to help!.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
JS
Jacquelynn S.
Robert McDorman was referred to us and…
Robert McDorman was referred to us and proved to be a truly outstanding partner throughout our claims process. A consummate
professional; he patiently guided us through the entire process, told us exactly what to expect, how long it would take, and how our insurance would behave throughout (and they did behave badly). He was always available to answer any question day and night. I highly recommend anyone involved in an auto accident contact Robert and his team and let them help you through the claims process whether for a total vehicle loss or diminished value claim.
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsOct 4, 2019
Thank You so much Mrs. Saxer for taking time to issue us a review. I enjoyed working with you and your family thru this sensitive situation. I hope for your sake you never need us again. However, if you do please call on us. Thanks again for believing in us to help you with your sensitive motor vehicle claim situation.
Sincerely,
Robert
LT
Lynn Teague R.
Auto Claims Specialists are THE BEST
Auto Claims Specialists are THE BEST! When we first started our discussion, we had a balance to pay on our loan due to the low insurance settlement we received. Auto Claims Specialists worked with our insurance company and showed them they undervalued our vehicle and then negotiated to get additional money on our settlement. Without them, we'd be making loan payments for 4 additional months. They are knowledgeable and diligent and helped make us whole. We're extremely happy with the outcome and the assistance Auto Claims Specialists provided. They fully resolved our case!
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsSep 14, 2019
Thank you for your kind words, Lynn. We are appreciative of your GAP provider, ForeSight Services Group, for their referral and for helping us come to appreciate the vast scope of this indemnity issue. Internally we refer to cases such as yours as liability realignment cases, where primary insurers are attempting to improperly transfer some of their liability onto secondary providers, secondary providers are naturally pushing back at the unexpected and unfair allocation to their books, and insured’s such as yourself are getting caught up in the middle often holding the bag. Once you discovered that you were under-indemnified for your loss and invoked your right of appraisal, an accurate appraisal of your vehicle's value at time of loss shifted the correct percentage of loss back to your primary carrier, leaving a fair balance that ForeSight was more than happy to cover – and leaving you free and clear on your loan. Unfortunately, there are insurers, including yours, who are now attempting to prevent policyholders from reopening their claims and exercising their contractual right of appraisal. If you had come to us just a week later, you would likely still be stuck paying the cost of an unfair settlement. At Auto Claim Specialists we are working diligently to educate and compel insurers to honor their appraisal clauses in cases such as yours where you didn’t discover that you were being under-indemnified on your loss until after settlement.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
JM
Janet M.
Thanks to everyone that worked on my…
Thanks to everyone that worked on my claim. I will recommend this company to others. The customer service was great . Keep on top of everything. GREAT JOB THANKS AGAIN
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsSep 14, 2019
Thank You so much Ms. Motley for taking time to issue us a review. We enjoyed working with you.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman
MA
Mr. Aikshii W.
Highly recommended
Highly recommended, not the cheapest but worthwhile!
I have been arguing with my insurance company for two months, but they just do not compromise for any value increment of my car which was totaled from flooded.
Chad was very professional and explaining the situation to me.
Three week later, the car value was increased much higher than expected. Great job!
Response from Auto Claim SpecialistsSep 8, 2019
Thank You Mr. Wong for taking time to issue us a review. We enjoyed working with you. If we can help you in the future please call on us.
Sincerely,
Robert L. McDorman