Trading Made Simple - VIP PlanReviews of tradingmadesimple.org

It genuinely makes me sick to see this marketed so heavily to retirees and people looking for supplemental income when the results being shown are based on simulated trading and, from what I have personally observed, do not translate reliably to a live trading environment. The response is always that “past performance doesn’t guarantee future results,” “market conditions are difficult,” or “Autopilot is just a structured educational approach.” But that does not square with marketing that emphasizes passive trading, recurring income, automation, and lifestyle freedom. Retirees are paying enormous amounts of money for these programs. Before anyone spends $10,000–$20,000, they should ask to see complete verified LIVE brokerage results, including all wins, losses, slippage, commissions, and drawdowns. Practicing in SIM is one thing. Using SIM performance to create confidence in a system’s live profitability is something else entirely.

This program is heavily marketed as a “set and forget” trading system compatible with both ThinkorSwim (TOS) and IBKR. My experience shows that this is not true for IBKR, and the gap between marketing and reality is significant. I joined specifically for the Autopilot and Swing trade alerts, not coaching. I was told that as someone with prior options trading experience, I would not need a coach, so I did not enroll in the $12,000 lifetime coaching program. Instead, I planned to pay $3,000 for the annual program, with the option to later upgrade to $6,000 for lifetime access to Autopilot and Swing trades. I paid $1,500 upfront, but after encountering major issues, I realized the program was not suitable for me. IBKR Compatibility Issue On IBKR, stop-loss and take-profit orders are not anchored to the actual fill price. They remain fixed based on the market price at the moment the order is submitted. This makes it impossible to execute percentage-based exits reliably and completely breaks the “set and forget” promise. Despite following the training videos step by step, asking questions in the Ask-Sandy Discord channel (Nov 18, 2025), raising the issue again by email on November 26, 2025, and being advised to contact IBKR directly, IBKR confirmed this behavior is platform-level and expected. This contradicts what I was told by the company. As a result, I cannot set and forget these trades. I must manually adjust exits after fills, and sometimes I miss them. This defeats the purpose of Autopilot. Performance Concerns Even with only one contract per trade, after less than two months: • Swing trades resulted in approximately $4,000 in unrealized losses • Autopilot trades were also negative over recent months For an alerts-only service, the risk-adjusted performance does not justify the high price. Other services provide better results at a fraction of the cost. Refund Policy There is no 30-day refund policy. Even if you realize within weeks that the program does not work for you or your broker, you are stuck. When I declined to pay the second installment due to ongoing failures, my request for a proportional refund was refused. Why so many 5-star reviews? Most positive reviews focus on coaching, not the actual alert performance or execution results. Once someone pays $12,000 for lifetime coaching with no refund, there is little incentive to leave an honest negative review, even if dissatisfied. Bottom Line • Marketed as IBKR-compatible – not true in practice • “Set and forget” – impossible on IBKR • High cost – poor performance • No safety net – no refunds This is a clear case of marketing versus reality. If you are an IBKR user, be extremely cautious before enrolling.

They keep you informed on most things having to do with the stock market. The problem I have is you pay for the program but you can't start learning until you talk to a coach. Basically, it's someone that's gonna try and upsell you . I can learn the same thing without having to buy and take years to pay for a VIP membership.

I went through the material, attempted to set up my Think or Swim platform, and could not even see the SHARED information in my platform. When I spoke to a representative on a Zoom call he was all about getting me to fork over additional $8000 to get into "everything" that the system supposedly does. Maybe it works, maybe it doesn't I really have no clue at this point. I couldn't even paper trade with the platform to try out the examples. Very discouraged and truly feeling taken advantage of, I went into this in good faith and came out poorer for the exchange.

They make you jump through hoops for refunds (almost impossible to get) so be careful or you will waste $197.00