Find the highest quality italian gourmet products at the lowest prices in our online italian supermarket. Shop for the best, authentic Italian food online at SupermarketItaly.com!
SupermarketItaly.com (supermarketitaly.com) has 257 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Website
supermarketitaly.com
Category
Grocery Stores & Markets
Location
Lyndhurst, New Jersey
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 1% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Horrible don’t send your item when they told me on the phone they would .they lie and say they will highly disappointed don’t answer e mails awful I’m sorry I ordered and $8.99 shipping for real come on guys! e bay sent my item the next day hello that’s service!
NO
norman
Absolutely zero communication from SMI…
Absolutely zero communication from SMI concerning shipping info. I explicitly warned them off using FedEx and strongly encouraged USPS for my order, since I live in a very remote area. They ignored my preference and I only found my purchase three days after they asked me for an opinion on their performance. It was found over a tenth of a mile on the side of a logging road in the Klamath National Forest. It was heat damaged after being suspect to three days of above 90 degree temperatures. SMI promised to make good on their defective product, but they never followed up and have not returned emails, phone calls &tc. Absolutely unprofessional and not worthy of one's trust. Can I possibly give a zero star review? That's what is deserved for my experience.
ND
Nicole Dal S.
Expired food for sale
Expired food for sale
TO
Tommy
Zero customer service
I placed an order 09Dec22.I received part of the order 15Dec22. The packing slip said it was complete. I was missing 6 items, and customer service is horrible. Spoke to virtual chat, said my order was complete, then said it was shipped in 2 parts. I should have received the second one yesterday, No order, FedEx says it is delayed.
Do not try to call the phone number, 35 calls, no one answers.
CO
Cindy O.
Two very unfortunate experiences
I have had some unfortunate experiences with this online store. I was excited to receive the nduja which is a spicy, spreadable type sausage/salami. I should not need to be cooked but can add a great flavor to sauces, etc. In teeny, tiny print on the package, after a night of bad food poisoning, their nduja has on the package must be cooked to 160. Great. Glad I only ate a little on my homemade Italian bread. I complained and got a refund. Before complaining I received a complimentary large bottle of Brioschi Sodium bicarbonate. Right.
Second, I ordered two 3-lb packages of DOP gorgonzola at close to $160. I get an email the next day stating there is only one left, and they refunded that one. But the communication back, and forth, was not clear if they were going to send the other one and when. It was frustrating. I finally received the one 3-lb gorgonzola after 2 weeks. It was delivered opened, watery, smelled horrid, and the foil around the cheese was torn. Once again, I took pictures and got a refund. I will not be ordering from them again.
AD
A.D. B.
Expired Organic Food Items
I ordered several items from them including organic lemon juice. When I finally received the order, the lemon juice had expired on 8/31/2021 — last year! When I alerted cust svc by email they didn’t respond but refunded my money. What reputable business sells expired organic merchandise? I didn’t even receive an apology. They probably thought I wouldn’t notice. I will never order from them again.
MD
Mr. D.
Very unprofessional and poorly managed
I placed a large order, received some items that expired beyond the expiration date. Other items were not as described on the website. I tried calling during their posted hours they posted on the website after 9 AM, switched to another number that did not answer after multiple tries. I tried doing the live chat, their instructions say to click on the bubble at the bottom left-hand corner of the page, after many attempts I found the bubble on the right-hand side of the page. Very unprofessional and poorly managed.
MF
margot F.
They sent me the wrong order
They sent me the wrong order. Fine. I can understand mistakes happen. I contacted them and they said they would send out the correct order. That was over a month ago. They keep saying that it has to get sent out at the beginning of the week and that's the hold up, but that's crap. Also, they have never once apologized. This was not a mistake I made. Just one I got to pay for and not have what I ordered to show for it. These people are horrible at customer service and I wouldn't trust them with your money or your time.