Find the highest quality italian gourmet products at the lowest prices in our online italian supermarket. Shop for the best, authentic Italian food online at SupermarketItaly.com!
SupermarketItaly.com (supermarketitaly.com) has 257 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Grocery Stores & Markets · Westville, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · East Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · Monroe, New Jersey
Excellent
Showing 202 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Nancy W.
I live in rural GA and shop with this place routinely - always outstanding products, service, notifications, shipping and customer service. Why even try to go out and buy Italian with Supermarket Italy. Amore, amore, amore!
george R.
Best prices for amazing ingredients. Shipping is a tiny bit slower than Amazon. But the prices, packing, and quality are far worth it.
Cesca
Every shipment is packed with care. They carry excellent quality products. No wonder things sell out so quickly! Highly recommended.
LaurieL
Fun and interesting extensive selection of grocery items. Stocked up on a variety of sauces, seasonings, pastas. Prices were reasonable. The packaging was hysterical! Everything wrapped extensively...just like my Italian in-laws! Nothings going to break on delivery with this packaging. I have saved the box and wrapping for my son's next move! Fast delivery. All good. Will be a regular shopper there.
Loretta B.
I've made at least four purchases from Supermarket Italy and have only been happier with each one. The site is easily navigated and has a great variety of products from different countries. The Sicilian lemon jam was wonderful and the Greek olives are being finished by the jar full ! Every single item is carefully wrapped in either a thick layer of bubble wrap or sturdy brown kraft paper. Never any breakage. We get to try new items that we might not have tasted in the past because it's so much fun to shop here.
D. M.
Outstanding! I found website when in search of Fregula Pasta and Clam Juice for a recipe I wanted to try. All my local grocery stores have limited specialty items. I got carried away because of the gluten free selections they had as well. Over a $100 later for items I just came across and ordered, I got nervous because of snowy weather. All items arrived timely, undamaged, and extremely well packed with care. Box was on porch when I got home from work. Thank you Supermarket Italy !!! 🇮🇹
Consumer
Nice selection and good prices. Easy to navigate website. Prompt efficient service and delivery. Was initially put off buy some of the negative reviews, but I have nothing but praise.
Anil M.
Purchased Kimbo Nespresso capsules with request to ship immediately. Very happy experience with purchase, communication & shipment. Will buy again.