Sterling was acquired by First Advantage on October 31st, 2024. First Advantage (NASDAQ: FA) is a leading provider of employment background screening, identity, and verification solutions. Headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia, First Advantage performs screens in over 200 countries and territories. Visit the Company’s website at https://fadv.com/.
Sterling, A First Advantage Company (sterlingcheck.com) has 3,953 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
sterlingcheck.com
Website
sterlingcheck.com
Category
HR & Recruiting
Location
New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 18% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Their employees are unprofessional, their policies are not transparent and they are not fair to candidates. Moreover, Sterling has in some cases deceived its employer clients about their ability to verify and obtain information. Legislation in many countries does not allow commercial organizations to receive information about arrests, priors, and criminal records. What information then, and where do they get it from? But the main thing is the sales "service", right Sterling? Beware of this company.
GD
Gina D.
Form extremely buggy and got crazy…
Form extremely buggy and got crazy slow. No amount of clearing cache or restarting computer helps. Logs you out with no timer and does not save your work! As others have mentioned the address area is a nightmare. It keeps trying to find your address even when you want to manually type it in. It then messes with the country. If country gets removed and you fix it it removes the address. I agree with others that the exact dates need to be gotten rid of. It takes forever and also does not tell you how far back to go just not to leave any gaps. I clicked next and it had deleted other info like state for driver's license and it made me go back. Tick tock! Called support and they were aware of the time-out issue and the saving work issue. Mind boggled that employers continue to use them. And I heard the reports are slow. I hope not. We shall see. So frustrating, wasted an entire afternoon on a 20 minute form. It also says you may need to upload documents so have them ready. Does not specify which ones. Just two "maybe" examples. Not an issue if you don't have a timer and it saves your work!
AD
Adrian
Unprofessional people which makes me…
Unprofessional people which makes me think twice if my data will get sold to other agencies because they not competent enough to understand how in uk adress needs to be typed..Scammers who avoid getting In touch ...don't recommend!!! Very bad experience with this company is unbelievable!!!
IP
Irina P.
unprofessionalism and outright sabotage
The hiring company, Bausch & Lomb, engaged Sterling to conduct a background check on my candidacy with an expected timeline of 7 to 15 days. I uploaded all the comprehensive documents into their system and started waiting. After two weeks, the company requested a couple more documents, and after dragging out the check for a month, they issued a report stating that:
They were unable to contact my former employer (even though I provided all necessary company contacts, colleagues' contacts, and tax authority letters confirming tax payments at this workplace).
They were unable to verify information about my criminal record in my country of residence.
I contacted my former colleagues and found out that no one had called them, no requests were sent to the official email, and apparently, no verification of my previous job had been conducted at all.
I requested an official document from the Ministry of Internal Affairs (Police) of my country stating that I have no criminal record, arrests, or other criminal records and sent it to Sterling, whose employees simply refused to accept and verify this document.
I tried to open a dispute on this issue, but I was also refused. Meanwhile, I wasted a lot of my time, spending half an hour waiting for operators on the phone, who would transfer me from one department to another, each time clarifying the details of my case again.
In other words, Sterling did not obtain the information and did not complete the check. The question is, why are you then taking money from companies and for what?
As a result, the hiring company Bausch & Lomb lost me as a promising employee (even though I had previously received an offer), and I lost the opportunity to work.
I am confident that Sterling's incompetence causes significant economic damage to its clients and the United States as a whole.
LG
Laura G.
Keep asking for information i have…
Keep asking for information i have already provided, if they cant do a background check with licence, passport, utility bills, signed by a civil servant, what do they actually do?
AN
Anonymous
This company is beyond incompetent
This company is beyond incompetent, multiple requests for the same information both to myself and my referees to the point it could be considered harassment. A website that is virtually impossible to navigate to provide said information unless you are based in the USA. Add to that the inability to accept that I may have spent a number of years living abroad. As for trying to speak to an actual human being... forget it!
If your prospective new employer tells you they use this company... Look for another job!!
GN
goalslife N.
Worsted experience ever STERLIN NO…
Worsted experience ever STERLIN NO COMMUNICATION AT ALL
AG
AJ-GREEN
Incompetetent company
Sterling have been tasked by Airtasker to carry out an identity check to verify my identity by comparing a copy of my driving licence to verify that the details within the licence are the same as the details on my driving licence.
The request was sent through to Starling on Thursday 13th June on 18th June I spoke to Airtasker who stated that they were still waiting for the identity check to be carried out. I spoke to someone from Sterling on the 18th June who stated that he could not tell me if the check had been carried out or if it was still in a queue because he was only allowed to give that information to Airtasker.
This is a joke. Why can't such basic information which is not personal information it is purely to confirm if they have done the check or not be provided to me. The only thing he could advise is to confirm that the time scales for them normally completing an identity check is 12-15 working days but stated some times it can go over this time frame which also does not help in working out whether they would have done the check or not.
The other concerning thing is he kept calling it a background check rather than an identity check. I have only agreed to an identity check which is comparison of a copy of my driving licence which I have supplied and not for my personal data to be used in any other way.