Stay Kitty Stay Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of staykittystay.com

Stay Kitty StayReviews of staykittystay.com

5.026 reviews
Pet Services
115 Franklin Turnpike, Suite 115 (mailing address), Mahwah, New Jersey

Call Directions Website

Stay Kitty Stay

About Stay Kitty Stay

Stay Kitty Stay is a cat only facility where cats stay in custom built kitty suites that are available in various sizes and prices. We are a small facility which allows us to give each cat guest individualized attention during their stay. We have 10 cat boarding suites that hold from 1 to 6 cats comfortably. Long term stays can be accommodated! Each suite was designed to keep cats happy and secure. Each suite features all glass doors, windows that look out onto a garden, cat climbing & scratching posts and plenty of stimulating cat toys, All suites that feature a window include the option of a secure private "catio" so your cat can get fresh air throughout the day!All cats are offered recess/play time throughout the day which allows them the exercise they need and keeps them mentally stimulated! During recess your cat will have the cattery room all to themselves (they will not interact with any other cat). Our staff will engage with your cat, play, brush, pet and basically give them whatever they need to make them feel secure and happy! We always let the cats lead how much interaction they want with us, and do our best to gain their trust during their stay!We are owned and managed by an all cat rescue organization, Felines For Adoption Cat Rescue. All staff/volunteers have had years of experience working with cats of all types of temperaments and medical conditions! We recommend that you book with us as soon as you make your plans, since we tend to book up quickly especially around major holidays and during the summer months!

Stay Kitty Stay (staykittystay.com) has 26 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.

Also known as: staykittystay.com
Website: staykittystay.com
Category: Pet Services
Location: Mahwah, New Jersey
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 35% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2025.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Pet Services

Stay Kitty Stay reviews

26 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Wayne C.
May 5, 2025
Kate is super nice and provides a…
Kate is super nice and provides a superior experience for our kitty Bagle. Kate has been boarding out pets for several years (4 or 5). This is a five star establishment.
Report
Bess C.
Feb 24, 2025
Katie is a caring host
Katie is a caring host, she loves the cats so much you can tell. Hats off, Kate.
Report
Caroline T. L.
Jan 10, 2025
Hospitality
Efficiency, hospitality/kindness and a very reasonable price!
Report
Tariq R.
Oct 5, 2024
Our cat’s home away from home
Kate is amazing at what she does. A true cat lover, she really understands how to make our cat feel at home and comfortable, and also make us feel secure during his time there. I especially love that she sends daily pics and vids, which also feature her playing and interacting with our cat. Our cat is pretty timid and shy, and being away from home is always tough for him, but somehow Kate makes him feel comfortable here. Dare I say, I think he’s a little sad to leave when we pick him up, and he especially misses the catio!
Report
Valerie
Sep 30, 2024
Cats were well cared for during our trip
The facility was extremely clean. The space for each cat allowed them plenty of space and the outdoor catteries kept them entertained. We liked that we were able to check in on them via the camera set up in each indoor enclosure. Would definitely recommend.
Report
Kerry-Ellen S.
Sep 27, 2024
We love Stay Kitty Stay!
I am so thankful for finding StayKittyStay for our cat, Wasabi. We just adopted him last year and had our first vacation coming up. I was nervous about finding the right accommodation for him. SKS was perfect and so welcoming to me and him! My kids felt great that Wasabi would be loved and cared for while we were away. I will be using SKS for all our next vacations!
Report
Elaine Del C.
Sep 19, 2023
Another successful stay at Stay Kitty…
Another successful stay at Stay Kitty Stay. Kate is fantastic. She is patient and kind and this time my cat Sadie actually let her touch her. I believe this was my cats fourth time staying there and she thoroughly enjoys her patio and I enjoy getting pictures knowing that my for baby is well taken care of. Highly recommend using Kate and will be back in three weeks.
Report
J L.
Aug 30, 2023
Wonderful help during an emergency!
My cat and I were visiting friends in the area. Unfortunately, I had a silly accident and broke my hip, placing me in the hospital and rehab for a couple weeks. My friends were leaving for vacation so my cat Hobie needed a place to stay. Stay Kitty Stay was recommended by other friends. SKS was extremely easy to deal with and very helpful, bending over backwards to make Hobie comfortable and communicating with me to keep me updated. They also sent me photos and videos.
Report