Shirt Mystery Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of shirtmystery.com

Shirt MysteryReviews of shirtmystery.com

3.6190 reviews
Ball Games
12 Proctor Drive, Mesa, Arizona

Directions Website

Shirt Mystery

About Shirt Mystery

We are the most affordable destination for high-quality mystery football shirts from clubs and national teams around the world. Whether you're a collector, a fan of surprises, or just love the beautiful game, our mystery boxes bring excitement and football culture straight to your wardrobe.Each shirt is carefully sourced and checked for quality before being sent out — you’ll receive a premium replica in brand-new condition, all at a great price. We work hard to provide a fun, fast, and reliable experience for football lovers across the UK and beyond.Join thousands of happy customers and discover your next favourite shirt!

Shirt Mystery (shirtmystery.com) has 190 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.

Also known as: shirtmystery.com
Website: shirtmystery.com
Category: Ball Games
Location: Mesa, Arizona
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 1% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: July 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Ball Games

Directions Write a review

Shirt Mystery reviews

190 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Joe W.
Jun 10, 2025
Both shirts are fakes and come from…
Both shirts are fakes and come from china, neither are particularly good fakes either
Report
Paul G.
Jun 8, 2025
Inter Miami and Real Madrid tops
Ordered two tops 2xl. Received 2x slim fit ( Real Madrid (purple) and Inter Miami (pink). Both cling like a second skin (it’s not a pretty site and not helped by the colours). Stitch quality in one was poor (Inter Miami). I had tried both on so option of returning wasn’t available based on returns policy. Unfortunately I have to say I’d be reluctant to buy again.
Report
Mr Stuart R.
Jun 6, 2025
Quality kits
WOW, ordered two football kit for my sons and they absolutely loved them. The fit and quality is top notch and would highly recommend 👍🏽 Thank you 5⭐ service.
Report
Joel O.
Jun 4, 2025
Really good customer service and the…
Really good customer service and the shirts are amazing quality and really good
Report
Matthew
May 29, 2025
Always a great mystery shirt
Always a great mystery shirt ! Never had any complaints so good
Report
Janice L.
May 28, 2025
Nice shirt
Nice shirt but of all shirts to come was Miami club shirt ( which you cab get that stuff in primark ) so wish had been a different club shirt i was expecting a Barcelona after reading reviews. Ill buy again was happy with qaulity etc
Report
Dean T.
May 19, 2025
The badges have foil on them meaning the production of the top hasn’t been finished.
I have ordered from you a number of times without any issues and I’m aware that the product isn’t legit jerseys, but today I have record tops which aren’t finished. The badges and sponsors still have the plastic foil where you have pressed them on. I have tried to peal the Madrid badge and now the badge is coming off. Not happy.
Report
Nils H.
May 17, 2025
Took time but really lucky
It took some time to deliver but thats probably becauyd its from UK but im really happy with the trikot
Report