Tim S.
They told me my poster was authentic
EDIT: I decided to edit my review since my real complain is with the authentication company. The customer service from poster memorabilia has been pretty good and based on research they seem to rely on the authentication companies to provide them with authentic items. That being said, I still believe that they need to choose real verified companies to authenticate things they are selling. It looks like they have removed the Stranger Things posters from their website as I assume they realized they are not authentic, which is good by them. They told me my poster was authenticated so I went ahead and purchased, well the company that did the authentication was called authentified ai. Well I have been collecting a long time and am close with all the local memorabilia and card stores and no one has heard of this company. They say they use PSA and Beckett but not this poster. I sent it in to Beckett and all of the signatures on the poster failed authentication. I asked them to return which they obliged. I wish they listed which items were actually authenticated by legit companies.
Response from Poster MemorabiliaDec 2, 2025
Hi Tim, Thanks for the feedback. We stand by the authenticity of every poster we sell — that’s non-negotiable for us. At the same time, we want every customer to feel completely supported. If this piece didn’t meet your expectations, you’re welcome to return it under our 90-day money-back guarantee. Just reach out to us at [email protected] and we’ll take care of it right away. Warm regards, Team Poster Memorabilia