David
Waste of time...
I asked PGS to evaluate my collection that contained the items listed on their website (see below) in very good condition. They took it, held for a several weeks, and told me they were not interested without evaluation/appraisal (which I didn't mind paying for). I was not in a hurry, but... I didn't mean just storage but appraisal. PGS states this : "Perhaps you’ve already resigned to sell your stamp collection or parent’s stamp collection, but aren’t sure who buys stamps near you, so that old box of stamps remains in storage with no use to anyone. Maybe there was a point you already tried to sell your stamps or stamp collection, only to find there was little interest and few resources in your area to inquire of. Did you ask neighbors, friends & family “Is there a stamp dealer near me that buys stamps?”. When you are ready to sell your stamp collection, PGS Gold & Coin stamp buyers have multiple coin shop locations where you can have your stamps appraised, and where you can sell the whole stamp collection. PGS GOLD & COIN STAMP BUYERS COLLECT THESE TYPES OF STAMPS: Mounted Foreign Stamp Collections China, Korea, and Asia Stamps British and European Colonies Russia..." If nothing else, I wanted to know what my stamps were worth (in their estimate). Their radio ad, "PGS, PGS, when it comes to your valuables, it's the best" might be true for themselves but not for me.
Response from PGS Gold & CoinJan 12, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We’re sorry for the frustration caused by the longer-than-expected turnaround — that part is on us, and we understand how waiting without clear communication can feel disappointing. We did complete a free evaluation of your stamp collection. Unfortunately, what our specialists found is that the material consisted primarily of post-1930 stamps. In today’s collectibles market, stamps from this period generally have no resale or collector value beyond face postage, regardless of how well they are preserved. That is why no formal paid appraisal was recommended — an appraisal would not have changed the market value or resulted in a sellable collection. Our website lists the types of stamp collections we actively seek — such as pre-1930 issues, rare international collections, and specialized or historically significant material — because those are the categories that retain collector demand. We always provide free evaluations first so customers don’t spend money on unnecessary appraisals when the market does not support it. We appreciate you giving us the opportunity to review your collection, and we regret that the outcome wasn’t what you hoped for. If you ever have additional items or questions about collectibles, coins, or precious metals, we’re always happy to take another look. Feel free to reach out to a manager with any additional questions Mon-Fri via phone 847-348-6447 or email: [email protected] — PGS Gold & Coin