New York Stay - The one stop URL for New York accommodation, apartments, hotels, hostels, guest houses, bed and breakfasts and last minute rates for New York. Find your New York accommodation at New York Stay, All New York apartments accommodation with just one click. New York Manhattan apartments to sleep nightly and weekly. New York hotels and new york vacation hotels in the city.
NewYorkStay.com (newyorkstay.com) has 28 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Website
newyorkstay.com
Category
Hotels
Location
New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 4% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: February 2018.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
There was a great level of communication between me, my partner and the guys who helped us at NewYorkStay to ensure we had the best possible experience ever. It was extremely pleasant and the whole process was easy.There was no problems checking in and me and my partner stayed for 4 days. The apartment was lovely and even though I would of liked a bigger kitchen everything else was great.
I had great comfort when I slept in the bedroom and there was plenty of comfortable and luxurious furniture to use and relax on, everything was clean and there was plenty of space apart from the kitchen which was just a tiny bit smaller than I expected but even so it was great! Also a very lovely area of new york. I'll use again.
KR
Kristin
Little Italy loft - 2 bdrm, not 3 as advertised. NYStay great to work with!
Had a great booking experience with Chandra, and a good check in experience with Marlon. We stayed 5 nights at an apt in the heart of Little Italy on Mulberry St. Although advertised as a 3 bdrm, it's actually a 2 bdrm with a 3rd bed partitioned by bookcases in the living room, and a pull out sofa bed. This was not ideal or what we expected - the two people staying in that bed got little sleep due to the noise and lights from the living area. The other two bedrooms were quiet and fairly comfortable with portable heaters keeping it very cozy. The kitchen was well stocked with dishes, but needed a microwave and/or pots & baking dishes. There was no way to heat leftovers except with a frying pan. The full size fridge, gas stove and two full sinks were nice, though. We also enjoyed the large dining table, and lots of room to spread out in the large living room. Being right above several excellent Italian restaurants was wonderful, and made late night dining possible. The closest subway are about 4-6 blocks away - green and yellow lines, and they took us just about anywhere we wanted to go in uptown, downtown or midtown. We took the J train from the same stop out to the JFK Airtrain very inexpensively (although the whole trip took about 1.5 hours). Overall, I'd recommend it for the proximity to Soho, Little Italy and Chinatown, but think carefully about the bedroom placing (bring earplugs and sleep masks for the front room). Hopefully the owners will consider building a 3rd bedroom in the large dining space back by the other two rooms to make a real 3rd bdrm.
AM
Annika M.
Great personal service!
It was easy to get in contact, with NewYorkStay, both by phone and email. Workes fine with payment, keys, everything. The apartment was totally ok. NewYorkStay were the only ones that could offer us a three room apt for a week w short notice, didn't find anything on airbnb, craigslist et cetera.
Only reason I don't give five star is the fact that renting short term is illegal in NYC, and therefore the whole business is a bit strange. We had a visit by the police, a bit scary, but they let us stay.