Monument Traders Alliance is a financial publication, software company and community dedicated to helping everyday folks invest and trade smarter, profit faster, and live free. We've helped tens of thousands of people grow their wealth through our chatrooms, which offer proven ideas, expert insights, and top-tier LIVE financial education... And we provide top-tier research through our multiple publications and trading scanners, developed to help everyday folks gain an edge in the markets. Regardless of your experience... we're here to help find the next profitable trends and take your goals to the next level!
Monument Traders Alliance (monumenttradersalliance.com) has 197 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Also known as
monumenttradersalliance.com
Website
monumenttradersalliance.com
Category
Education Services
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 78% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Some trades worked and some didn’t. Overall, not seeing a great return for the money.
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi There,
Thank you for your review. Nate has a roughly 63% win rate year to date in Daily Profits Live, and a roughly 68% win rate in Profit Surge Trader year to date. Please reach out to us directly and let us know how we can help you in your trading journey to more align with these wins, and give you a 5-star experience in the future! Reach out to us on the moderation team in the mod tab for your services. We are here to help!!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
JO
JOEL
Great trading resouce
Monument Traders Alliance has been a good source of helpful information and online guidance and interaction. It's great to catch Karim and Bryan's ideas and I follow Nate Bear's trades. I've had subscriptions for several years now. 👍
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi Joel,
Thank you very much for sharing your experience with us. We are happy to have you and truly pleased to see you are having a 5-star experience!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
JH
Jeff H.
Not Enough Guidance on Managing Open Trades
I only have a 49% win rate with PST. I find that I am stopping out of many trades while Nate SELDOM reports on closing out trades for losses. With a win rate in the 70s%, he must have some but we, again, seldom get stop out alerts. We're more likely to get "buying more to trade out" alerts. For newer options traders like there are in PST, these are higher risk adds on low delta options. For example today he added to GTLB, which we opened at $3.10, at $0.95 on a .25 delta option. If we were going to add, it might have been good to do so on the way down, not after we were already down 70% and received ZERO updates. In summary PST doesn't provide enough guidance on managing open trades before they become big to near total losses.
Nate is a good teacher of technical analysis, and PST is a low cost service.
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 28, 2026
Hey Jeff,
Thanks for the feedback here. Depending on the situation, Nate will often let his cheap "lotto"-style trades ride, and he usually will communicate his intent on the live stream or within the entry alert.
He also gives updates during the livestreams.
This is good feedback, though, and we can try to be clearer in these scenarios.
If you have any more feedback please reach out to me directly at [email protected]
Thank you,
-Stephen Prior
Publisher
JL
Jean-Luc C.
I appreciate the knowledge of Nate Bear…
I appreciate the knowledge of Nate Bear and the simple way he transmits it.
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi There,
Thank you for your review. Please reach out to us directly and let us know how we can make your experience a 5-star one in the future! Reach out to us on the moderation team in the mod tab for your services. We are here to help!!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
ED
Eddie
Great value for the reasonable price
Profit Surge Trader helps one decipher from all the millions of stocks and options possible, the best ones to trade. It's most beneficial how Nate explains everything he is doing and warmly invites us to ask any question about trading. The subscription price is most reasonable.
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi Eddie,
Thank you very much for sharing your experience with us. We are happy to have you and truly pleased to see you are having a 5-star experience!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
BR
Billy R.
Live Trading that makes you money
Good about explaining trades and gives lots of profitable trades .Teaches you along the way and answers tour questions in real time. i bought a one year membership and after that a lifetime memership
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi Billy,
Thank you very much for sharing your experience with us. We are happy to have you and truly pleased to see you are having a 5-star experience!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
PB
Pizza B.
Swing trading with Nate
The education from Nate.
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 30, 2026
Hi There,
Thank you for your review. Please reach out to us directly and let us know how we can make your experience a 5-star one in the future! Reach out to us on the moderation team in the mod tab for your services. We are here to help!!
- Jordan
Monument Traders Alliance
EG
Eric G.
I took Nate Bears Sector Strike and I…
I took Nate Bears Sector Strike and I was taking every one of his trades with a paper account and after 60 days I was down around $20,000, it seems like he doubles down on losers using options, he did have some winners but the losers were far greater than the winners so I canceled the subscription, what people don't realize is these people were good in times past when the market was good but the market we got now is very tricky that is in 2026, just my opinion not saying they're all bad but that's my experience and also I was pretty close on getting the same price as him, it was just a terrible service but maybe it has something to do with the time of the year but I could not use it, it was totally useless for me.
Also I think you should know there's gut wrenching ups and downs in your positions because of the options and it would just drive me out of my mind,, the service it's just not the way that I trade, I got taken in by the sales presentation but it was nothing like what they had in their sales pitch, at one point I was almost profitable after a big $7,000 win and then it all just crumbled and I stopped after the 60 days being down like I said around 20,000
Response from Monument Traders AllianceSep 17, 2026
Hey Eric,
Stephen Prior, Nate's Publisher here at Monument Traders Alliance.
I'm sorry you had a bad experience with us; however, your 11 PM review is just false.
Nate's track record (from his broker account) as of last Friday (9/11/2026- we review our expert's track records every Friday afternoon) was 13 wins on 14 losses year to date... with an average win of 47.34% in 12.1 days (including his loser).
It certainly has been a rough market (for most investors) over the past few weeks... so it's plausible he took a loss or two this week (will need to check during business hours), but as of last Friday he was 1-for-1 on the month with a 107.13% win (in 6-days) on CEG ... so clearly his losers aren't "far bigger" than his winners.
His all-time track record in that service is 33-for-43 (a 76.7% win-rate) with an average return (winners and losers) of 23.17% in 18.3% days... many of those 10 losses came back in early 2025 at the beginning of the service.
Here is a summary: https://share.zight.com/01a0ae2b-092b-78e8-bfdc-7dea0f74314b
So very clearly there is disconnect between Nate's performance and the performance you outline above. At the end of the day, Nate is not your broker or money manager. He can just educate, provide his research, and trade recommendations. As you can see here, we have many happy members.
Nate now does 2-hour-long livestreams every month teaching the strategy. We have hours and hours of training and recordings of his lessons...
And most importantly, we have a real moderators available to help answer questions (including providing track records) via our mod chat to help point you in the right direction.
Nate also does Q&A in the chatroom during his livestreams.
You did not include any contact information w/ your review... so maybe I don't have your correct account, but from what I believe is yours... it doesn't look like you've asked any questions over the past few weeks. I could be very wrong here, though.
Still, I'm happy to hear more about your experience ([email protected]) and the trades you made over the past 60 days and happy to share with you a copy of the track record spreadsheet we keep on Nate's Sector Strike Service w/ the full trades.
Again, I am sorry that you had a bad experience with us. This review is disheartening to see , but ultimately I am glad you started with paper trading and were able to cancel your subscription with the money-back guarantee. Many of our competitors don't offer that, but we want members who are happy with our services and are getting good use. I'm not sure why there was such a big disconnect between the service's performance and yours ... but obviously, not everyone will be happy and we believe you should not trapped if the service is not for you.
Please reach out to me at [email protected] with any additional information or if there is anything else we can do to help (including Nate's track record)
-Stephen Prior
Publisher
Monument Traders Alliance
