Amelia
Would give negative stars if I could
Would give negative stars if I could. They "forgot" about my order and shipped it weeks late, only after I reached out to ask them where it was. When it arrived, it was missing the free gift that was supposed to come with the order. Then both pieces tarnished within 3 days of wear, and when I reached out for a refund, I stopped receiving emails from them. I have sent three follow up emails without a response. Definitely a scam - their pieces are NOT real gold, they tarnished way too quickly. They also gave me a tracking number via instagram DM instead of the website - likely so I was not able to leave a review on their site. Pretty sure all their 5 star reviews are fake.
Response from Mason & Madison Co.Jul 31, 2025
Dear Amelia, We’re deeply sorry to hear about your experience, and we completely understand your frustration — from the delayed shipping to the missing gift and lack of follow-up. At Mason & Madison Co., our goal is to deliver beautifully crafted jewelry, honest communication, and a seamless experience, and it’s clear we fell short for you. Please reach out to us again at [email protected] with your order details so our client care team can personally prioritize your case. We will process a full refund or replace your pieces with upgraded options that meet your expectations, and we’ll also ensure your promotional gift is sent at no additional cost. To those reading: while this customer’s experience was understandably disappointing, it does not reflect the experience thousands of our clients enjoy with Mason & Madison Co.. We’ve recently strengthened our quality control to ensure lasting durability, improved our communication systems, and updated our review process so all authentic customer feedback can be seen. Choosing Mason & Madison Co. means trusting a brand that stands behind its products and its customers. We would be grateful for the opportunity to make this right and show why so many clients continue to choose us with confidence and satisfaction. Thank you again for your feedback—it’s important to us and helps us improve. Best, The Mason & Madison Co. Team




