They are Trash. The reviews on their website are Trash. I had a vehicle that Carmax offered me $9500 for and Givemethevin.com offered me $200. Don’t waste your time.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
We’re sorry to hear you were disappointed with your offer and appreciate you sharing your experience. Vehicle values can vary widely depending on many factors — including condition, mileage, market demand, and history — and our offers are based on current wholesale market data. We never want anyone to feel like their time was wasted, and we’re always open to reviewing any valuation concerns.
We also understand how frustrating it can be when expectations and offers don’t align. If you’re open to it, we’d love another chance to take a closer look at your vehicle details. Please reach out to us at [email protected] so we can try to make this right.
Thank you for considering us — even if we fell short this time.
NU
NoName U.
Submitted vehicle info for an offer then ghosted
Submitted vehicle info for an offer. They responded with a fair offer. The agent who had been fairly prompt with replies and such, suddenly wouldn’t respond to any messages. I don’t know any legit business which suddenly ghosts potential clients. I ended up submitting the vehicle info to Carvana and within 2 hours I had a check in hand.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
Thank you for your feedback — and we’re truly sorry for the lack of follow-through you experienced. That’s not the standard we strive for. Once we make an offer, we aim to provide clear and consistent communication throughout the process, and it sounds like we missed the mark.
We’re glad you were able to sell your vehicle quickly elsewhere, but we’d still appreciate the opportunity to review what happened on our end. If you’re willing, please email us at [email protected] so we can investigate and improve.
We appreciate you giving us a shot, and we hope to earn your trust back in the future.
JY
Justin Y.
They back out of deals
I was working with Ryan from Give Me the VIN. We negotiated a price on my car, Ryan confirmed and accepted the deal on my car. I sent Ryan all of the requested documents and told me his manager would get the paperwork started. He told me where to take the car & the title and I could pickup a check. Ryan then changed the delivery location and wanted me to pay for a condition report of the car. I told him I didn't want to pay for a condition report so he backed out of the deal. I had already provided Ryan with 10 pictures of the car and the car has no damage to it. Ryan waisted a lot of my time. I feel it's extremely bad business to make a deal with a customer then back out of the deal.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
We’re sorry to hear about your experience and understand how frustrating it was to have the deal change after you’d submitted everything. While we try to honor every offer, sometimes additional info or requirements — like a condition report — can affect final steps.
We appreciate your time and effort, and we’re reviewing this internally to improve communication going forward. If you’d like to reconnect, we’d be happy to take another look. Please feel free to reach out to us at [email protected].
Thank you again for considering us.
TI
TIMOTHY
Company Owner Is Unprofessional
Received an offer from givemethevin.com and an identical offer from another company. I asked givemethevin when they could get my car and never heard back from them. I accepted the other offer and told givemethevin. I got an email from the company owner who accused me of being dishonest. I explained to him that he had me confused with another customer and that I had done exactly what I should have done. I never heard back from the owner nor did I get an apology for calling me dishonest. I will never do business with this company.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
Thank you for your feedback — and we’re truly sorry for how this situation was handled. It sounds like there was a clear miscommunication, and we understand how upsetting that must have been. You did nothing wrong, and we regret that you were made to feel otherwise.
That’s not the experience we aim to deliver, and we’re addressing this internally to prevent it from happening again. We appreciate you giving us a shot, even if we fell short, and wish you the best moving forward.
CH
Chris
BEWARE!
BEWARE!! Absolutely ridiculous offer. They advertise they give a better price than other places, but they offered a price junk yards would offer. I realize I'm bias because I like my car, but when Carmax and a dealer offered $1500 to buy it, but show me the vin offered a only $500, I couldn't help but laugh. I would not use this service without checking with other places because you'll definitely make more money. This place seems to prey on the desperate. BEWARE!!
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
Thanks for your feedback — we understand how frustrating it can be to receive an offer that doesn’t match your expectations. Our pricing is based on real-time wholesale market data, and in some cases, that can differ from retail or dealer offers.
That said, we always encourage customers to compare offers, and we’re glad you explored your options. Our goal is never to “prey” on anyone — just to provide a fast, honest offer based on current values. If you’d like us to take another look, we’d be happy to do so. Either way, we appreciate you considering us.
LC
Lara C.
A Slimy Deceptive Company
They seemed professional when I first contacted them and gave me an offer that beat my carmax offer so I wanted to go with them. However when they sent someone to do the last inspection, pick up the car and write the check. Things went south. They told me that they couldn't take the car for what they offered because it had more damage than what I reported which was a complete lie. They said that the bumper was falling off and wouldn't even match or beat the offer that carmax gave although it says they will beat carmax's offer on their website . I don't know if it was because we were older women and thought they could get away with it or if their business model just plays good cop bad cop. I ended up not selling to them because they wouldn't even match carmax's offer. I'm also supposed to get $100 for trying them according to their website but I know they won't do it as they also said they wouldn't even beat carmax's offer. I don't understand why they would think someone would go with a significantly lower offer or if the mobile inspector just didn't want to do his job that day. Reading other reviews, it seems like they do this for the $250 they charge you if you don't go with their offer. SELLER BEWARE. PROTECT YOURSELF FROM GIVEMETHEVIN. DO NOT CALL OR TRY TO SELL YOUR CAR TO THEM UNTIL YOU HAVE AN UNEXPIRED CARMAX QUOTE IN HAND SO YOU KNOW WHAT YOU CAN REALLY GET BEFORE THEY TRY TO GET SLIMY WITH YOU.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
Thank you for your detailed feedback. We’re truly sorry your experience didn’t go as expected. We pride ourselves on transparency and professionalism, and it’s disappointing to hear that you felt misled.
Our process includes a final physical inspection to verify the condition of the vehicle matches what was submitted. If there’s a discrepancy, it can affect the final offer — but we never aim to play games or take advantage of anyone. We also take accusations of bias or unfair treatment very seriously and will be reviewing this internally.
We’ve helped hundreds of thousands of customers nationwide and regret that we didn’t meet your expectations this time. Your feedback helps us improve, and we appreciate you considering us.
PE
Pete
Greedy, Slow to Respond, and Shady.
I've worked with givemethevin in the past and used to have positive experiences. However, in recent times, they have declined significantly in service. They don't respond to emails or text messages, and it seems like they purposely delay their response so that your vehicle value will diminish. In my most recent case, they let the rival offer expire in order to avoid paying out their $100 "promise." Don't waste your time with them; just use a dealership or an alternate service to get your business done.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
Thank you for your continued business in the past — we’re sorry to hear your recent experience didn’t live up to the standard you’ve come to expect from us. That’s never what we want for any customer.
Please feel free to contact us at [email protected] with the offer and vehicle info. We value your feedback and hope to have the chance to regain your trust.
LH
Lyn H.
GMTV lied about the $250.00 “ONLY” applying to dishonesty of the seller.
In the FAQs you will find this: Q: “Why is there a $250 breakup/unwind acceptance on a purchase order to buy my car?
“A: This ONLY applies when a seller has not been honest. We take you at your word when providing information about your vehicle, and once we strike our deal, we incur many expenses in keeping our end of it. We believe people generally keep their agreements, and know you would understand that we experience losses in the event you suddenly change your mind after accepting our deal.”
This is NOT truthful. I was honest with them with all aspects of the process. Unfortunately, the day before my appointment we experienced a death in our immediate family that flipped everything on its head. I texted them and shared this information and canceled the appointment more than 24hrs before it was scheduled. Almost immediately I was sent the following response from them:
No worries. There is a $250 fee to break the agreement. You can remit payment to:
Givemethevin.com
8721 Airport Freeway
North Richland Hills, TX 76180
No concern or even regret to learn of the situation. Their focus was solely on getting the $250.00. I think this says a lot about the people you are dealing with. I was always honest with them from the start. I certainly will not return to them to sell my vehicle once we get through unfortunate loss in our family. Nor will I recommend them to anyone. Just sell it yourself…you will come out ahead.
Response from givemethevin.comJul 30, 2025
First, we want to express our sincere condolences for your loss. We understand how difficult and unexpected life events can be, and we’re truly sorry that our response didn’t reflect more empathy during such a challenging time.
Regarding the $250 unwind fee — it’s intended to protect against losses incurred after a formal signed agreement has been made, such as transportation scheduling, paperwork processing, and title coordination. While our FAQ states it applies to situations involving dishonesty, we also apply it when a seller cancels after accepting a signed deal, as operational costs are still incurred. That said, we understand how this can feel unfair when personal emergencies arise.
We’re reviewing how we communicate these policies to ensure clarity and compassion are balanced.
Again, our deepest sympathies to you and your family during this time.