First Premier is a Nationwide Home Warranty company that offers affordable plans to protect your appliances & Major systems in your home.First Premier is also proud to offer a special discount for Healthcare Professionals, First Responders, and Active-Duty/Veteran Military members.Call us today to hear more about our Discounts and Promotions!
First Premier Home Warranty (firstpremierhomewarranty.com) has 474 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.5 out of 5.
Also known as
firstpremierhomewarranty.com
Website
firstpremierhomewarranty.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Brooklyn, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 20% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I can never get in touch with them. I have been on hold for at least TWENTY MINUTES every time I call, only to have someone come onto the call and disconnect me. I have been trying to request reimbursement for repair expenses and have been unable to receive some form I need to sign to begin the reimbursement process even though I have been told four times that I would have it by the end of the day. I am so frustrated with them. The reason we had to do it this way is because my repairman could never get through to get an authorization number. I wish I had never heard of this company. Just try calling them!
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Karla, we apologize for the hold times and for the reimbursement form not reaching you after repeated promises. That should have been a simple step. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Stanford," and we will send the form directly and confirm the next steps for your reimbursement.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
JO
Joyce
Problem receiving help. Poor customer Servic
I called on 9-15-26 to report a pipe that leads to my furnance was leaking. On 9-16-26 I was sent the name of a company called Sure Plumbing. I called them and was told they did not work for you!! I called back on 9-17-26 and spoke with JESSIE again, explained I needed another technician and she gave me the name of Pipe Pro. Called and spoke with Joshua, he asks me to send him a picture of what was leaking. He then told me I needed an HVAC technician.
Called back on 9-18-26, spoke with NOAR, was told she would be sending out a person within 24 hours. Called back on by 9-21-26, spoke with CARMEN, she stated they were having trouble finding a technician in my area. She went on to say she would let me know something by the end of the day. Never heard back from her. I have called back twice, after speaking to CARMEN. I spoke to one very RUDE person who would not give me his name. He stated that it was being processed within 24-48 hours. I asked for a supervisor and was told there were no supervisor and hung up!!!
I called again on received the same treatment,no name given, said I would receive an email within 24 hours. RUDE
Called again this morning and was told I would have someone by the end of day, refused to give name.
I have never encountered such rude customer service in my life. I have even sent a email to ISAAC EDWARDS, who convinced me you all were such a great company. Of course he hasn’t answered!!Before my purchasing the warranty, he couldn’t stop emailing me. I have also tried calling him???
My previous company cost more, but I never had these problems. As they say,”you get what you pay for”,
I am sure half of these called were not recorded or if so I am the rude person.
I hope someone understands my frustration and get me some help because since my original call I have noticed other water!!!!
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Joyce, thank you for the detailed account, and we're sorry for the runaround you experienced after reporting the leak on 9/15. Being referred to companies that couldn't help and then not hearing back is not how a claim should go. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Joyce," and we will assign a technician and follow up with you personally.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
ER
Elaine R.
Don’t do business with this company
Don’t do business with this company. They promised a paper contract which hasn’t been produced in 6 weeks, even with repeated requests. Very hard to contact. I want to cancel the contract, but they are refusing.
If they won’t provide a paper contract that was promised what else will they not do that was promised
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Elaine, we're sorry the paper copy of your contract hasn't reached you despite your requests. You're entitled to it, and we will send it. Please email [email protected] with your mailing address, marked "Trustpilot – Roddy," and let us know if you'd still like to discuss cancellation — we'll handle both.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
DO
Don
I tried phoning your company two weeks…empty office
I tried phoning your company two weeks before I finally got someone to answer phone ( although I had one pickup and someone said a nasty remark and hung up).I cannot do business with a company like that . Therefore I am cancelling my contract . I needed help setting up the portal.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Don, we're sorry for the difficulty reaching us and for the way one of those calls was handled — that is not acceptable. If you'd like help setting up your portal or wish to proceed with cancellation, please email [email protected] marked "Trustpilot – Don," and a team member will contact you directly.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
GW
george W.
flim-flam scam artist, do not trust
just days after signing up, i had questions no one returned my emails nor my many phone calls, i then left messages to cancel and refund my credit card no response! and never have spoken to a live person, i filed a complaint with my credit card company, i feel violated scammed! run from this company they are not real!
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi George, we apologize for the lack of response to your emails and calls after signing up. That's not the start you should have had with us. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Waller," and we will confirm your cancellation and refund in writing.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
MA
Marlene
I have been assigned to three different…
I have been assigned to three different technicians, #1 could not come to service my refrigerator until 9/30, #2 said he would call me later to get info and schedule, NOT, never heard from him again, I called #3 yesterday and he said he would have to get back to me after he had time to check his service requests and schedule. I have been waiting since 9/12 for service and am extremely displeased the lack of service!! I sent you 2 e-mails to you @ the address you indicated and they were both returned as not a valid address. I WANT THE $399.01, I PAID YOU FOR SERVICE I DID NOT RECEIVE. I HAD TO PURCHASE A NEW REFRIGERATOR AND YOU SHOULD REIMBURSE ME FOR THE COST. POLICY # FP-018413. STOP STALLING AND CORRECT YOUR CHEATING WAYS.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Marlene, we're sorry for the delays on your refrigerator repair and for being passed between technicians since 9/12. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Marlene," and we will secure a confirmed appointment and follow up with you until the repair is complete.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
MB
Mark B.
tried to call for help with a…
tried to call for help with a cancellation and could never get thru. continually hung up on wasted 1.5 hours of my time.
Then i sent and email to cancel and never got a response.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Mark, we apologize for the hold times and the unanswered email regarding your cancellation. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Buchine," and we will process your request and send written confirmation.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
EW
Ellen W.
Are you kidding?
Are you kidding?? I've already instructed my bank to not honor this initial payment from two days ago. I have not even received a contract - nor is it online. So, the only way I can cancel is through my bank. And, what I've read about other people trying to get refunds or payments for services is also unlike what I was told by the agent! I have, since opting to change my service to First Premier, - discovered that they lied to me. They have not been in business 30 years and their customer reviews are abysmal! I guess you pay for what you get
Let me just add: I called last week and spoke with a customer service rep again, following a email to the young man who signed me up, indicating my wish to cancel. I was told I' d get a call back in 24 to 48 hours from your cancellation people. I did NOT! Its no wonder you have a bad reputation!
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Ellen, we're sorry you haven't received your contract and that your early experience didn't match what you were told. Please email [email protected] marked "Trustpilot – Ellen W," and we will send your contract immediately and address any questions about your policy or payment.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team