First Premier is a Nationwide Home Warranty company that offers affordable plans to protect your appliances & Major systems in your home.First Premier is also proud to offer a special discount for Healthcare Professionals, First Responders, and Active-Duty/Veteran Military members.Call us today to hear more about our Discounts and Promotions!
First Premier Home Warranty (firstpremierhomewarranty.com) has 474 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.5 out of 5.
Also known as
firstpremierhomewarranty.com
Website
firstpremierhomewarranty.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Brooklyn, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 20% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Absolutely horrible experience!!! I've been paying them for 4 years and never needed them. Then our water heater started leaking and when we called them it took FOREVER for someone to answer, IF someone would answer at all. They hung up on me when I started asking questions. I asked to speak with a manager and they gave me the infamous line "they're not available" and put me on the call back list and of course I never got a call back as of yet. RUN!!!
MA
Marto
This company should be out of business…
This company should be out of business bad customer service, it's like they don't know what they are doing. My A/C broke down on 100 degrees I called them for a technician they told me they didn't have technician available, told me I can called my own technician & sent them the invoice I did they never responded nor reimburse me. They are crooked, rude, poor customer service. QThey sent a technician number to call, when I contacted him, he said he doesn't have no business with this company they don't pay him. I had bad experience with them. Stay away from them. If they have zero I will a give them zero star.
DW
David W.
Mom has this warranty and its…
Mom has this warranty and its apparently junk, she has called and called asking for her furnace to be looked out and here 3 mos later still nobody. Be winter and probably freeze with no heat. Dont recommend at all.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi David, thank you for bringing this to our attention, and we're sorry your mother has been waiting this long on a furnace issue with winter approaching. That is not acceptable, and we want to get a technician to her right away. Please email [email protected] with her name and policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Weatherman," and a member of our team will contact her directly to schedule service.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
KC
Kimberly C.
Absolutely do not recommend this…
Absolutely do not recommend this company! My mother has been waiting for a refund for over 6 months. they keep saying its in the mail or just hang up on her. We now have to take them to court. absolute scam of a company to take advantage of an elderly person!
I attempted to email the company as requested and the email failed to send to the address given.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Kimberly, we're sorry for the delay and for the frustration this has caused your mother. A refund should never take six months, and we want to resolve this now. Please email [email protected] with her name and policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Costa," and we will confirm the refund status and timeline in writing.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
RC
Robert C.
Absolute terrible service
Absolute terrible service
lie mislead
waiting over 4 months for a check for $175.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Robert, we apologize for the delay on your reimbursement. Four months is far too long, and we'd like to get this resolved for you. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Cella," and we'll confirm the status of your check and when you can expect it.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
RD
Rhonda D.
I put in a claim 9/22
I put in a claim 9/22, but have not received any response still 10/2 so I called. The lady told me they sent me an email. I have not received any emails regarding my claim. She gave me a techs phone number. I called they said they do not work with your company that I need to call and see if they will reimburse me. I called and have sat on hold for 25 and 45 minuets and then been hung up on. I would like a call back and some information on how I am suppose to go about getting services. I paid full price for the warranty up front. I should not have to work this hard to get a service I paid for.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Rhonda, we're sorry for the experience you've described — a claim filed on 9/22 should have been handled well before now, and the referral and hold times you encountered are not the service you paid for. We'd like to make this right. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Devencenzi," and we will call you back to get your claim moving.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
MM
Marcos M.
Total Fraud: Useless Technicians, Ignored Emails, Zero Support
First Premier Home Warranty is, without question, the most useless, dishonest, and infuriating company I’ve ever dealt with. Every interaction with them feels like a trap designed to waste your time, drain your patience, and leave you with absolutely nothing.
I’ve spent hours on hold, multiple times, listening to their terrible automated system while they pretend to have “high call volume.” The truth is simple: they don’t care. They don’t care about customers, they don’t care about service, and they definitely don’t care about honoring their own contracts.
When they finally bother to respond, they send incompetent, unreliable technicians who either never show up or provide laughably bad service. It’s almost impressive how consistently terrible their referrals are.
Trying to cancel the service? Good luck. They ignore every email, every request, every attempt to communicate. It’s like shouting into a void. They make cancellation intentionally difficult, hoping you’ll give up so they can keep charging you for a service they never provide.
This company operates with zero professionalism, zero accountability, and zero respect for customers. They waste your time, deny your claims, dodge responsibility, and disappear when you need them most.
First Premier Home Warranty is a complete scam disguised as a “service.” Save yourself the frustration, the wasted hours, and the financial loss. Stay far away.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hi Marcos, we're sorry to hear this, and we understand your frustration. Long hold times, unreliable technician referrals, and unanswered cancellation requests fall short of what we expect of ourselves. If you'd like us to process your cancellation or address the open service issue, please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Mancio," and we will respond directly.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team
SL
S.Lee
Worst home warranty company
Worst home warranty company. They do not have a good record with local companies and have to get companies outside local area. They lie about what repairman wrote in report in order to deny claim. They did not follow their own policy that request for cancellation has to be in writing and just cancelled policy and refused refund. They are not clear on the terms and conditions of their cancellation policy. If they happen to actually honor a claim and fix an issue and you try to cancel you will have to pay for that claim. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM. I am advising every realtor I know not to refer homeowners to them.
Response from First Premier Home WarrantyOct 5, 2026
Hello, thank you for your feedback. We're sorry your claim and cancellation experience left you feeling misled. We want to review what happened with your policy, the technician's report, and the cancellation terms that were applied. Please email [email protected] with your policy number, marked "Trustpilot – Lee," and we will look into it and follow up with you.
— The First Premier Home Warranty Team