Steven S.
I won a lot of 24 small/medium lot…
I won a lot of 24 small/medium lot cards for a total of about $1100. It took a month for Fanatics to send out the order. Went to my local Fedex office to pick-up the order and the said they returned the order to Fanatics because of expected fraud on their end (I have no idea what that means). I contacted their customer support and was put in contact with Rigo. It has been a complete joke since. Rigo could not find my order and emailed me multiple times saying he could not find it. Fedex did an investigation and said that Fanatics received the package back. Rigo had no clue about this. Fanatics put my order into my vault (completely against my wishes) and now wants to charge me an additional $132 to remove my cards from the vault and send them to me. Rigo said send the invoice number and he will take care of it. That was a week ago and still no movement. Rigo sent me an email yesterday saying it is company policy that for larger orders, it will take an additional 10-15 days to have it shipped. It is coming up on 50 days and I still have no order. Fanatics charged 22 percent and their customer is abysmal. I have been buying cards from multiple auction houses and ebay and have never been treated so poorly. Think twice before dealing with this company. My experience has been horrible.
Response from Fanatics CollectJun 5, 2026
Hi Steven, we're sorry to hear about your experience and understand your frustration. Our support team was able to locate your order based on this review - We will be reaching out with an update and next steps shortly. We look forward to making this right.



