Josiah J.
Sneaky auto subscription appears illegal & definitely unethical
Pros: Helpful at one point briefly with helping find childcare and assisting in voluntary background checks for nervous parents. Cons: 1. They charge all parties 2. Their sneaky auto-renew subscription model is unethical, probably illegal in CA & many states, and bad for consumers. 3. Few caregivers available locally compared to Sittercity (possibly because of frustrating experiences). Fees to all parties: bad UX and customer service prompted both us and our neighborhood babysitter to pay for her background check, with no refunds. Sneaky major annual subscription fees without reminders or refunds. This is horrible customer experience for busy distracted parents on a tight budget. I didn't know a ~$400 subscription renewal was coming till I saw it on our credit card statement. I contacted them promptly (most companies give me full refunds in these circumstances). Care.com refused to refund the full amount even though we haven’t used any paid features for 11+ months, and I contacted within days. They said the best they do is a complicated arrangement that still costs us $40. Sneaky auto-renewing subscriptions are considered unethical, and face growing regulation for consumer protection as some companies refuse to be ethical without explicit laws. As far as I can tell, their actions towards me have violated California laws that went into effect a few months ago. Looks like I missed out on the 2020 $1M class action lawsuit they lost, and I will keep my eyes out for a new one since they keep breaking the law. P.S. A simple search for "are auto renewing subscriptions unethical" or similar will show ethics and legal arguments. Regulations are currently state-by-state as consumer complaints rack up, but federal regulations may come soon.
Response from Care.comAug 29, 2022
Hi Josiah, I'm so sorry to hear that you were not aware that our memberships auto renew until cancelled. This information is included on every upgrade page, as well as our billing confirmation and Terms of Use. If you'd like to discuss further, please reach out to us through the contact us link at help.care.com or through Facebook messenger. Please include Reference Number REV-006541 when you message.



