AV
Ben Garelick is the best local jeweler
Ben Garelick is the best local jeweler. They are courteous, professional, and go above and beyond to work with you.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Thank you! We truly appreciate your review.

Find the best jewelry selection, style, quality and service when you visit Ben Garelick. Offering eye catching diamond engagement rings and a fine jewelry selection, our experienced staff will help you find the perfect piece. Whether it's an engagement ring, an anniversary gift, a ‘push present’ for a new mom or just a gift for a special someone, we’ve got the perfect size, cut and color for every occasion. For over 60 years, Ben Garelick has helped thousands of clients make holidays, weddings, birthdays and anniversaries extra special.
Ben Garelick (bengarelick.com) has 52 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 5.0 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Huntington, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Brooklyn, New York
Excellent
Showing 52 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
AV
Ben Garelick is the best local jeweler. They are courteous, professional, and go above and beyond to work with you.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Thank you! We truly appreciate your review.
Danielle
Just love the wedding bands we purchased!! The service was great, I loved working with Peter Sr. We had a couple bumps in the road where the wrong size band was ordered for my husband a couple of times but they made it right by overnighting the correct band so we had it in time for the wedding! Thank you!! We will shop there again!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Sizing wedding bands can be a bit of a process, but we always want you to be comfortable and happy in the end. Can't wait to see you again soon!
Kevin
Peter Jr. and Sr. are by far the best at price, quality and most of all service. Peter Jr. went out of his way to get my setting in ahead of the promised date to make everything work out. I wish I could give them six stars, but compare them for yourself
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Kevin, thank you for your 5+ star review. Comments like yours make our days sparkle!
Susan
I had a special order with engraving. Everyone was pleasant and handled my unusual requests with care. i would highly recommend them.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Thank you for your review.
Matthew
About a month ago I found myself in a very tight situation. The local jeweler I was using for my fiancés engagement ring jerked me around every which way possible. At the time, I thought all hope was lost in obtaining the ring before our vacation that I had planned to propose on. The very same evening I left the jeweler with no hope I came across Ben Garelick online. It wasn't very long after I discovered their website that I had received an email back from Peter Manka Jr. Not only was Mr Manka able to get his hands on the engagement ring I was in search of but he was able to pull a miricle and expedite the process to meet my deadline just in time. I live in Illinois. When it came to deciding what diamond was chosen for the ring, the decision was made between Mr Manka and his jeweler. In all honesty I was a bit worried because I couldn't see it in person. All I could do is have faith. Words cannot describe how perfect and beautiful the setting and diamond turned out to be. I owe a big thanks to the team at Ben Garelick. Without them I wouldn't have had the ring in time for the planned proposal. From the customer service, to the product, to quality of the entire experience, I rate this outfit 5/5. I will go through them for any future jewelry inquiry's and purchases. I would highly recommend Ben Garelick to anyone and everyone. Once again, thank you for playing a big part in such a beautiful moment in my life. Thank you.
Response from Ben GarelickAug 30, 2017
Matthew, your review made our day...week...month...year! So glad we could help you pull off your proposal as planned. We know it can be worrisome to buy diamonds online, and are so glad that we were able to meet your expectations. We do tease our diamond buyer by calling him a "sparkle snob," about the only time being called a snob should be considered a compliment! We look forward to helping make many future occasions sparkle for you and your fiance. Congratulations!
Maria Romine for D.
Staff are very responsive, quick, and great customer service. Thank you!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Thank you!
Chris
Extremely happy customer! Great service, speed of shipping and all done from the other side of the world seamlessly!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Extremely happy we could help! Thank you Chris.
Lori
Trustworthy advice, fast service, excellent experience!
Response from Ben GarelickAug 29, 2017
Lori, you'll never know how much your review means to us. Thank you!