Zane N.
UPDATED REVIEW 2/5
UPDATED REVIEW: Been following Alertsify since the beginning as updates come out, most of the issues has been patched took a process though and early testers got hammered by the bugs but it was to be expected with a early product. Thats why I stayed on the sidelines watching and observing traders before deploying more capital. Should never have happened. People shouldn't of been the test subject for something so early. __________________________________________________ *** Takes months or even years of data collection to determine if copytrader won't blow your account, and you have to pay for that risk with 99$/mo fee/200$ fee + required copytrader fee (70-200$+) All the golden traders the screenshots were advertised as profitable... (TOM, FATHER, ISERRA, DANNYMTB) All lost people money. Advertised in the screenshots as profitable, slowly faded away losing people money. DannyMTB has 1800 trades, so if he had that many trades in 8 months time and in the end he ended up with -0.49% ROI. It will take a years of data collection to know if they are a good trader. You were slammed with monthly alertsify fees (99$ + Danny's subscription fees) just to not make a profit. (792$ lost in Alertsify fees following Danny) Tom was profitable everyone followed him, he started charging and turned out he didn't know what he was doing. Lost people money. Faded away into the dust. Point is...With the amount of money your going to be forking out with Alertsify, monthly fees and/or subscriber fees its just not worth the risk knowing someone can blow your account a year later after following them. __________________________________________________ Mixed reviews on if the STC (Sell to close) bug is fixed, reddit users are reporting losing money due to their copytrade positions not closing and stuck with 100% loss and then getting kicked from discord group. Once you leave a review you can't edit it. I left a 5 star when the platform was fresh with a little better traders and now I can't edit it. ^ Still a thing, reviews can't be edited once reviewed on whop. Alertsify (2k+99+marketplace fee / 200$ a mo) vs NVSTLY (Free) / Peakbot (Monthly fee) or even cheap manual discord alerts Alertsify looks like its doing free advertising and users are reaching out to other discord groups for traders and if your not on Alertsify you lose creditability which I completely understand. *** Lastly, Don't always trust marketing cause screenshots show only profits, when in reality its mixed. One good month is shown, and 3 bad months arn't. Many of the screenshots advertised on EM / MP / X page are just in the moment profits. When you look on the leaderboards page the accounts are severely low ROI or even blown by the time you view it. Makes the platform look untrustworthy if you ask me. Promising returns that just are not there in other months. "Wow X user made X amount of money this trade" *pulls up leaderboard* "Wow they suck at trading", thats the norm of Alertsify right now.
Response from AlertsifyJun 15, 2026
Zane, appreciate the detail. You’ve clearly been around since the start, and feedback like this is more useful than any 5-star. A few things worth correcting: Pricing’s moved since you joined. The setup fee is gone. PRO is $249/mo flat, there’s a $99/mo tier for signals without auto-execution, and a free view-only tier. The numbers you quoted are from the old model. On the traders, you’re actually describing the feature working. The reason you can pull up DannyMTB’s -0.49% over 1,800 trades is that every trader with verified fills is forced onto the leaderboard. No hide button. The bad stretches don’t disappear. A platform optimizing to look good shows you one green screenshot and buries the rest. We show the whole record, because copy trading carries real risk and we’d rather you see it than get sold a cherry-picked DM. We’ve never claimed a trader can’t have a bad run. Past performance isn’t a promise, and that’s posted everywhere. Also let’s be clear about what we do and don’t claim. We don’t guarantee profit. We never have. Trading is extremely risky and people can and do lose money, that’s posted on every page. Yes, we share customer wins, because they happen and they’re real, but a win on one trade is never a promise about the next one. Past performance isn’t a guarantee of anything. The leaderboard exists precisely so you can see the full picture instead of just the highlights. The core thing you’re pointing at, that copy trading carries real risk and someone can have a bad stretch a year in, is true, and we say it everywhere. What we control is execution speed, verified fills, and a leaderboard nobody can game. That’s the platform. Door’s open if you want to talk directly. — Alertsify