A1tradingServicing Traders & Investors Globally Our goal at A1 Trading is to provide traders and investors with top level online communities, trading software tools, and informative media content. We are a team of trading analysts, developers, and management st...
A1trading (a1trading.com) has 244 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 17 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
Robert C.
Think you will find it just another con company , been here before .I would all stay away
Response from A1tradingJul 9, 2024
Hi Robert! We're sorry to hear you did not enjoy our products or service. I was unable to find a purchase you've made with us, but please feel free to reach out to our support email. We would be more than happy to see how we could help, or what specifically you had an issue with. Have a nice day!
Nicholas
Save your money to get a real mentor there discord u will learn nothing all trade ideas not worth it no narrative behind it he buys bull market sell bear market simple there is nothing to back these concept nice flashy YouTube video not much education
Response from A1tradingApr 6, 2024
Hello Nicholas. Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We value you sharing your concerns as it helps us to continuously improve our service! In regards to your explanation of our general approach to the market, you are right. We use a combination of fundamental analysis, technical analysis, and trend following. And we do also try intentionally to keep it as simple as possible! Also, if you are looking for a 1on1 mentorship program, that is not something we offer or advertise as part of our service. However, we do have some friends in the industry who do that sort of work. Consider checking out Dan Emmerson, or Eivind Bydall, as they have mentorship programs. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts. Good luck in your trading journey!
EK
Think twice or even more times before You purchase any service of this company. If it turns out that the product is not the right one for You or You do not like it, You will not get any refund. Although it is mentioned that refund is possible on a case by case basis within 7 days of purchase, just forget it.
Response from A1tradingNov 24, 2023
Hey Endre - thank you for leaving your honest review. I'm sorry to hear you've been unhappy with your purchase, but am confident we can assist you in getting the most out of your membership! Please send us a message on our support line at a1trading.com Due to the digital downloads nature of our products, we do have a refund policy that helps to protect us from people who purchase our products, download them, and request refunds. Feel free to message in any time, and we'll make sure to help you get the most out of your membership and clarify anything you need help with.
John
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit.
Response from A1tradingOct 24, 2023
Hey John! Thanks for sharing your review. First of all, I'd like to say that we are always available to assist with any questions or concerns you have. You can message us anytime at www.a1trading.com. I'd like to respond to some of your criticisms, as I honestly believe some points to be unfair to what we stand for as a business. In regards to the EdgeFinder's price point, it is totally optional whether someone chooses to purchase our tools or not. We do offer several free tools on our website for those unwilling to pay for our tools. However, the utility the EdgeFinder offers is what has led to our business' success, and our wide range of happy customers. Our software fulfills a need in the market for people who want an easy access UI for all of their market data, as well as interpretation and analysis of various market metrics. The EdgeFinder also offers analysis thanks to its underlying algorithm, which we do refer to as an "AI", as it does meet the definition. As far as the idea that if A1 Trading no longer was in business you would lose access to the tools, I would be happy to clarify this area. We have been in business since 2018, and plan to stay in business for many years to come. In the rare event that things change in this area, it would likely be the case that we would have been acquired by another firm, and existing customers would retain access to their products. In terms of trades shared in the discord, we share track record performance on our website, as we are very adament about staying transparent. We also show live brokerage logins on our website and YouTube channel. NONE of our trading results posted are faked or fraudalent as you mentioned, as we are fully aware of the legal implications that would have. In terms of trade updates, we share in depth updates throughout each one of our trades. As thoroughly mentioned on our signup pages, our trade alerts are not meant to be copied blindly, and it is expected that any members of our community do their own research. In regards to brokerage signup perks and partnerships, we do offer special signup perks that are in observation of regulatory requirements for each prospective client's country. This is apparent in our selection of offering these sorts of perks with well regulated brokerages for our global audience. Finally, we do not offer any sort of special perk, discount, or compensation to any review, and accusing our staff of doing something like that is unfair. In regards to our refund policy, our legal council has thoroughly reviewed our digital products, and done his due dilligence to present fair terms of service to both our customers and to our company. Please reach out to us anytime, and we'd be happy to chat further about how we can help you get more value out of your software & membership, and we hope that with time you choose to give us another chance and see the value we offer. Thanks again.
Jonathan B.
If I can rate with no star. poor support and poor content trust me guys the whole indicator and trading signals and the edgefinder you can find for free and it's a waste of money don't fall for it. ***another thing is that I asked for a refund after 24 hours and no one answered***
Response from A1tradingOct 22, 2023
Hi Jonathan, thanks for sharing your review, though we are sad to hear you weren't happy with our software! Though there are many free ways to view some of the same data that the EdgeFinder offers, it is unique in its scoring algorithm of the data it collects. It also offers a very user friendly UI to access all of the data you need in one place. We wish you the best in your trading journey!
Jake S.
Unfortunately, A1 Trading is not true to their claims despite their engaging and intriguing social media content. I have been a gold member subscriber to their discord service for over a year now. They claim to have experienced traders providing forex trades, which are said to be the same trades the traders take themselves and are responsible for the considerable growth of the trading accountings shown on social media. I however, have tracked these trades for over a year and I can confirm they are not profitable and in fact actually resulted in a draw down of a trading account by 45%. To this they may reply, our traders have ups and downs, which yes would be understandable but not when their accounts are unexplainably growing on these same exact trades in the same time frame. They may also reply saying these are not trade signals to be copied, rather just trade ideas, but these are claimed to be the same trades taken by the traders or analysts in their exact posted form who are experiencing growing accounts? A1 Trading use the image of being against fake forex glamorous lifestyles flexing Rolexes and Lamborghinis to portray a realistic steady rate growing trader, but in reality, unfortunately they have the same motive through expensive member access instead of commission earnings.
Response from A1tradingMar 1, 2023
Hello Jake, thanks for taking the time to leave us a review! At A1, we do our best to show conservative trading tactics and avoid promoting unrealistic expectations. Within our group, we have a list of experienced traders who all have several years of trading experience and their own unique styles of trading. Regarding the performance of these traders, I would ask you to reach out to our support line to better understand the trades - as our trade alerts have overall been profitable, as seen on the track record page of our website that tracks performance. We do not however suggest that you copy our trades blindly, as every trader has their own unique risk tolerance, availability / trading session, capital, and more. We (as indicated on our site and discord) share our trades for educational purposes. Regarding your concern about membership pricing, we currently have a staff of 9 people working behind the scenes to keep our community running, and has priced our memberships as competitively as possible to accomodate our company costs. I'm sorry to hear our discord community is not up to your liking, but wish you well in your trading journey and appreciate you taking the time to share your concerns.
Shishir N.
It is a poorly run service. I subscribed to A1 Trading one month ago and am subscribed to several other services. The level of professionalism exhibited within A1 is very low compared with the other services who charge same (or sometimes less). The material provided is without any predetermined format and several times just thrown over the wall without any explanation. I did not feel confident with any of the material provided primarily because I saw so many Stop Losses being executed. Please do yourself a favor and find another subscription service which would provide proper details and data points. You should be easily able to find them with some proper research.
Response from A1tradingFeb 3, 2021
Hello! I'm sorry to hear you weren't satisfied with your membership with us, but appreciate your feedback nonetheless. Our training material has been formatted/separated by beginner, intermediate, and advanced level in our resource library portal, and we would have been happy to answer any questions you had. Unfortunately we were unaware you were confused, as we did not receive any questions from you. Regarding "many stop losses being executed", our analysts (like all traders) have ups and downs, and experience drawdown at times. Trading involves taking both wins and losses, and is not meant for everyone. We wish you the best, and hope you find what you are looking for. Thanks again
Si W.
Didnt make any money off their signals on 2 attempts 👎
Response from A1tradingDec 2, 2020
Hello Si, I'm sorry to hear you did not enjoy our service. To clarify however, our group is not designed to be a signals copy service, but rather a place for traders to get ideas, improve, and collaborate. Assessing 2 trades is not nearly enough to gauge the skill of a trader, so we've provided track records on our website to show long term performance. Head over to our track records page to see performance over many trades.
