5-Star Insurance Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of 5starinsurance.com

5-Star Insurance Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of 5starinsurance.com

5-Star Insurance reviews

Showing 20 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

Elisa
Jul 9, 2026
Very attentive
Very attentive, polite, friendly and they help you and understand you.
Report
Jackson B.
Apr 14, 2026
Evan is the man
Evan is the man! Full transparency from someone in sales is a breathe of fresh air. If you wanna lower your rates. Go through this guy!!
Response from 5-Star InsuranceApr 15, 2026
Really appreciate that! Transparency is just how we operate, no games. Glad we could get your rates down and thanks for taking the time to leave a review.
Report
Corey C.
Mar 28, 2026
Highly recommend
Highly recommend! Cut my insurance cost in half!
Response from 5-Star InsuranceApr 15, 2026
Cutting costs in half is the goal every time. Thanks for the recommendation!
Report
Heather M.
Feb 19, 2026
Evan has been my agent and helped me…
Evan has been my agent and helped me navigate the FR44 insurance process. He has always been responsive, communicative, beyond helpful, professional, respectful about my situation, knowledgeable and continues to go above and beyond in helping find the most affordable rates. He is an asset to this company and I hope he is recognized for that. He even worked on a weekend to answer questions regarding my policy. I would highly recommend him as an agent to friends and family.
Response from 5-Star InsuranceApr 15, 2026
That means a lot, truly. FR44 can be a stressful process and I'm glad I could make it a little easier. Thanks for the kind words and for trusting me with your insurance needs. https://www.5starinsurance.com/fr44-insurance
Report
Megan Q.
Jan 30, 2026
Very fast and easy to get coverage
Very fast and easy to get coverage. The team is super friendly and helpful trying to get me the best deal. Recently added another car and it only took minutes!
Response from 5-Star InsuranceApr 15, 2026
Fast and easy is what we're going for. Glad the team took care of you and adding that second car was a breeze. Thanks for sticking with us!
Report
Pavel
Jan 29, 2026
What a smooth and efficient experience throughout…
People usually don’t write a review until it’s not good, but this was quite the opposite - so good that I’m writing one. The entire experience from A to Z was swift and smooth. Evan, who I was lucky to work with, was just so efficient and helpful with getting the best policy and price (and I shopped around), and made it so easy to even cancel it (I know some don’t make it easy and will reference some fine print) - which only made me leave with such a good aftertaste and perception about the brand. It truly was a 5-star experience, I’d genuinely highly recommend them, and will go back to them for any future insurance needs.
Response from 5-Star InsuranceApr 15, 2026
The fact that you noticed we made cancellation easy might be my favorite part of this review. No tricks, no fine print games, just straight business. Really glad the whole experience landed well and we'll be here when you need us again. Thanks for taking the time to write this.
Report
Kim T.
Nov 17, 2025
Best Service
Absolutely, hands down, easiest process. Evan was amazing and walked me through the process
Report
Kris M.
Nov 14, 2025
Evan was awesome
Evan was extremely knowledgeable and helpful with my situation. I’ve talked to several agents and nobody was able to help me until I called 5-star. It was quick and easy and Evan was very patient with me through the whole process
Report