Shirt Mystery Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of shirtmystery.com

Shirt MysteryReviews of shirtmystery.com

3.6190 reviews
Ball Games
12 Proctor Drive, Mesa, Arizona

Directions Website

Shirt Mystery

About Shirt Mystery

We are the most affordable destination for high-quality mystery football shirts from clubs and national teams around the world. Whether you're a collector, a fan of surprises, or just love the beautiful game, our mystery boxes bring excitement and football culture straight to your wardrobe.Each shirt is carefully sourced and checked for quality before being sent out — you’ll receive a premium replica in brand-new condition, all at a great price. We work hard to provide a fun, fast, and reliable experience for football lovers across the UK and beyond.Join thousands of happy customers and discover your next favourite shirt!

Shirt Mystery (shirtmystery.com) has 190 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.

Also known as: shirtmystery.com
Website: shirtmystery.com
Category: Ball Games
Location: Mesa, Arizona
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 1% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: July 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Ball Games

Directions Write a review

Shirt Mystery reviews

Showing 25 reviews with 4 stars · Clear filters

Matthew O.
Jan 17, 2024
Good quality but slow delivery
Ordered on the 5th January 2024 I received it today (16th January 2024) I received the 2023/24 man City third kit although I support man utd quite happy with the quality I ain't no bot review 4 star review due to the fairly slow delivery but in total a good quality shirt I can add to my collection of shirts just a shame I got unlucky with man City. I have also tried looking for the website again today to share with my friends but I couldn't find the website anywhere and when I type the link nothing shows so I haven't got a clue what's happened.
Report
Mustafa M.
Aug 9, 2023
very nice quality and shirt selections
very nice quality and shirt selections
Report
Sabeeh Q.
Aug 7, 2023
Really good
Really good, really helpful They listened to my request and gave me a great team. The only thing i would say is there is abit of a longer delivery time, but once i got the shirt it was TOTALLY worth it.
Report
Imtiaz A.
Jul 24, 2023
Love it
Great shirt and it was the official home kit of 23/24 bayern i love it will be ordering soon!
Report
Customer - S.
Jul 18, 2023
Ordered 3 tops in one order
** update following reply ** Whilst I appreciate the reply on here. I only reviewed on this site due to no responses from customer services to any of my emails. The ‘dispatched’ email link was not updated for 2 weeks hence my emails to check that it was in transit & not lost. Once the shirts arrive I will happily update the rating. Ordered 3 tops in one order - they haven’t turned up despite a “dispatched” email 2 weeks ago. Several email to ask for an update have been ignored - suspect it may be a scam.
Response from Shirt MysteryJul 18, 2023
In the email which notified you your item has been dispatched there is also a tracking link in which you can view how close to delivery your shirts are. Additionally, it is clear on the website that delivery overall takes 9-16 days. It is funny that you review us a 1 star rating before you even received the shirts, please wait for this to happen before making a judgement - especially as the delivery is still within the timeframe provided.
Report
Alfie H.
Jul 15, 2023
Perfect Mystery Shirt Company
Gassed with the shirt i got, came in secure packaging and was in perfect condition. had updates via email throughout the delivery process so i’m definitely gonna get another shirt asap :)
Report
David B.
Jul 5, 2023
Shirt Mystery is brilliant
Shirt Mystery is brilliant, got a real surprise. Reason for 4 down to delivery, took a while but even then when I contacted Shirt Mystery they responded quickly and followed up. Shirt is great quality, and have no complaints about the service at all. Actually ordered a second one while awaiting delivery and it came within 10 days (this one is a surprise birthday gift for my son, so not opened yet!). Will definitely order again!
Report
Aarush
Jul 4, 2023
Very good website
Very good website, got my kit within 10 days and the kit is in good quality.
Report