Miguel
Great gift options
They have great gift options. Super nice staff.

Sarah Elise Jewelry is listed under Jewelry & Watches in New York.
Sarah Elise Jewelry (sarahelisejewelry.com) has 106 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 67 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Miguel
They have great gift options. Super nice staff.
Chloe D.
Great experience and service!
BIK
Exactly as described and pretty! Ordered another one today to stack. Also very responsive seller.
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryApr 2, 2026
So happy you loved it and came back for another one, stacking them is the best look!
Tasha
I ordered 2 pairs of huggie earrings from Sarah Elise off Etsy. Having ordered solid gold jewellery from several different Etsy stores, as well as local gold jewellery retailers, and even brands like BVLA and Maria Tash, I personally am perfectly satisfied with the quality of the earrings I received. They are well made, sufficiently weighty, with no superficial flaws (uneven shapes / surfaces, scratches etc). Shipping was really quick as well. I received the package in Singapore within 3 days of it being shipped via FedEx. Customer service responded promptly when I reached out about some concerns regarding delivery. I've not purchased anything with stones so can't speak to that yet, but I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them for their solid gold pieces. They are true to the pictures and descriptions.
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryMar 24, 2026
This truly means so much to us, we really appreciate you taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review. It means a lot to hear that our pieces met your expectations, especially with your experience across other fine jewelry brands. We’re so glad you’re happy with the quality, craftsmanship, and overall experience, and that everything arrived to you so quickly. Thank you as well for your kind words about our customer service, it truly means a lot to our team. Enjoy your pieces and we hope to have you back again soon ✨💫
Songul E.
Had such a great experience with Sarah Elsie Jewelry. Their customer service was amazing. They really went out of their way to rush my order for a special occasion, which I truly appreciated. Beautiful craftsmanship and even better than I expected. You can tell a lot of care goes into their work. Highly recommend!
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryMar 24, 2026
So glad we could make it happen in time for your special occasion. It’s wonderful to hear you’re happy with the craftsmanship and overall experience. We truly appreciate your recommendation.
Liz
I purchased a bracelet from here that was too small, which was my fault. It eventually broke as it was too tight, not due to poor quality. I asked if they could repair and an extender and they responded quickly. Minimal charge for my request and the repair and extension was completed and returned to me in less than a week. I can’t say enough good things about their CS and quality. Thank u guys very much, will be purchasing from them again!
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryMar 24, 2026
So glad we could help you get everything fixed. Happy to hear the repair and extension worked out and got back to you quickly. We appreciate your kind words and look forward to having you back
Margaret
I LOVE Sarah Elise Jewelry! I've been an OG fan of theirs (following since around 2020) and they're legit. It's some of the best prices I've been able to find for gold because they make it all themselves. PLUS it's a woman owned small family business! Want to give them their support / flowers because I think some people don't know how to shop for jewelry online (read product descriptions right). I've had them make custom pieces, bought their original designs, everything has been great. They have been SO helpful with me while creating my fine jewelry collection over the years! Love!!!!
Response from Sarah Elise JewelryFeb 12, 2026
Hi Margaret, Thank you so much for your incredibly kind words and for being such a loyal supporter of Sarah Elise Jewelry since the beginning! We truly appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with our original designs and custom pieces. As a woman-owned, family business, we take great pride in handcrafting our jewelry to offer the best possible quality and value. It has been an absolute pleasure helping you build your fine jewelry collection over the years, and we are so grateful for your support! Thank you for being part of our journey! All the best Sarah Elise
Yavuz
I'm so impressed with the quality and design of Sarah Elise Jewelry! The details are stunning and you can really tell how much care goes into each piece. It arrived quickly and was packaged so beautiful too. Can't wait order again!!!
Response from Sarah Elise JewelrySep 24, 2025
Thank you so much for your kind words. We’re so happy you love the details and packaging, and we look forward to creating for you again soon.