PSAcardReviews of psacard.com

I went to use PSA last week after I found on their website up to $25 off for first time submissions. I signed up and went to order, but no code ever populated or received one in an email. I contact the support and I was told by Dylan I was feeling FOMO (Fear of missing out). There’s no fear of missing out, don’t advertise something you aren’t going to offer. Offers only go to select account holders. I responded with a link to their website describing the promotion and never received a response.

Terrible service they charge extra for a 15 day turn around. On the phone now with PSA who now claim it can take longer. How nice so do you charge more for that also?? As it is they charge extra for a 15 day turn around. Dont pay it. Its never done in 15 days. They are committing fraud. They can not turn it over in 15 days. Its still 30 days. They have no answer to how they can legally charge for a quick turn around they they are NOT upholding.

Spent over $300 to have cards graded. They screwed me on the grading. many cards I submitted were previously graded locally by a reputable dealer were graded much higher. I would never us their worthless service again!

Refuses to send magazines paid for. Lagging and unhelpful customer support. Wouldn’t use this company for anything

It’s crazy how we open these packs brand new and send cards out hoping for a 10 and a flying charizard comes back a grade 7. This is an absolute joke.

PSA must be hiring some very strange characters in attempting to catch up to their everlasting backlog. I too received an invitation for $50 off on a graded card. So I sent it in: to my eye, and magnifying glass, a beautiful example of a vintage Mantle card. They rated it a "2". I thought I must have missed something. When they sent it back, it was askew in the holder. It looked like an amateur had tried to imitate a real PSA holder. And I have been collecting baseball cards for about 60 years. I looked this card over in its holder: square, sharp corners, no creases, slight edge wear, no surface wear. A "2"? These guys had to be on magic mushrooms. First and last time I submit to PSA. I know more than they do.

Absolute nightmare company to deal with. I sent a high value Pokémon card and sold it through their eBay. They are so incompetent that they had no idea why my payment wasn’t going through for over a month. They finally tell me they lost my card through transit (aka STOLEN). After waiting, again, for the CRC to contact me, they offer me a refund. Cool I guess until you realize they take weeks to send you documents to sign. Also doesn’t help they will send a check that will supposedly be here in a month according to them. I wish I went with Beckett.

PSA grading is an absolute comedy show. I sent in my very first batch of cards: fresh out of the pack, untouched, straight from the manufacturer… and they come back with a 9. Meanwhile, a card that’s been passed around like a party favor, shoved in boxes, handled by multiple owners? That one somehow gets a 10. Makes total sense, right? And yes, I’m fully aware that new cards aren’t always flawless thanks to printing or packaging issues—but come on, the logic here is laughable.