Teresa J.
Worst Shopping Experience
I have been ordering on Black Friday for the past 8 years and over the past 3 years things have really gone downhill. I usually order a combination of their Men’s Staple Mystery Underwear & selected $10 Staple Underwear. They have a disclaimer when ordering the Mystery Underwear that duplicates are possible. In previous years I have received duplicates but it gets worse each year I order. This year I ordered 14 of the Men’s Mystery Staple & I received 14 of the exact same underwear. I couldn’t believe that not even 1 was different print or pattern. Oh and of course all Mystery Underwear purchases are final sale. I was extremely disappointed so I reached out to customer service & explained to the representative how ridiculous it was that I received 14 of the exact same underwear. She said she would be able to do a 1 time courtesy exchange on my order. She explained that she would be setting up a pickup for the order and I would receive a new order confirmation email that same day. Well 3 days later and I have yet to hear anything via email or otherwise. So basically she just fed me some B.S. and that was it. I spend $100’s of dollars a year with this company and after this experience I will never spend so much as $1 more dollar. If I could give then no Stars I absolutely would.
Response from EthikaDec 12, 2025
Hi Teresa, Thank you for your review. I do apologize for your experience with our mystery sale. We do try our best to add variety to these orders and it is clear that we missed the mark on this one. Since mystery items are considered to be final sale, we are not able to refund the items but we do offer a mystery exchange for duplicate items. Unfortunately, with this current process, we do not have a pre-paid label that would be offered to ship the items back, but we do cover the shipping to get the new order back to you as quickly as possible. We are currently reviewing our internal process for our mystery sale to see how we can improve this for all of our customers. We do apologize again for the duplicate items.



