Allfreshseafood.com Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of allfreshseafood.com

Allfreshseafood.comReviews of allfreshseafood.com

4.2213 reviews
Meat, Seafood & Eggs
89 East 42nd St, New York, New York

Call Directions Website

Allfreshseafood.com

About Allfreshseafood.com

The best part of All Fresh Seafood is that we have made it as simple as possible. We have an online store strictly dedicated to our national customers. From sushi-grade salmon and tuna to mussels, scallops, oysters, and more, we can ship our fresh seafood anywhere in the nation.But it doesn’t stop there. We also offer a wide selection of our chef-crafted seafood meals as well as a vast array of seafood products, cooking essentials, and assorted grocery items.To get started, simply visit the All Fresh Seafood online superstore, select what items you’d like, and place your order. And if you have questions about our national shipping, wholesale orders, or our seafood in general, we’ll be happy to help. Simply fill out our contact form to get started.

Allfreshseafood.com (allfreshseafood.com) has 213 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.

Website: allfreshseafood.com
Category: Meat, Seafood & Eggs
Location: New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 54% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

PJ Lobster House
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Port Jefferson, New York
New
1 review
1
OceanBox
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · New York
New
3 reviews
3
Great Moose Woodcraft
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Wells, Maine
Excellent
70 reviews
70
OC Wild Seafood
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Huntington Beach, California
Excellent
386 reviews
386

Allfreshseafood.com reviews

Showing 165 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

D L.
Aug 21, 2025
My sister and brother-in-law enjoyed…
My sister and brother-in-law enjoyed the lobster tail and scallop so much. They live in North Carolina and there’s no good seafood there so it’s wonderful that this company can solve that problem. Everything was fresh and tasty she said. Thank you so much for your company. It means a lot
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Dot, Thank you for sharing such a kind review! We’re delighted to hear your sister and brother-in-law enjoyed the lobster tails and scallops. It makes us so happy to know we can bring the taste of fresh seafood to places where it’s harder to find. Your support truly means a lot to us as well! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
customer
Aug 13, 2025
Lobster Tails
The product (lobster tails) showed up on time and were delicious! I fully recommend buying from this company.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Hello, Thank you for your wonderful review! We’re so glad to hear the lobster tails arrived on time and were delicious. Your recommendation means the world to us. We’d love to show our appreciation by sending you a gift card for your next order. Please email us at [email protected] , and our team will take care of the details for you. All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
US D.
Jul 30, 2025
Perfect Lobsters
I confess that I was skeptical about buying whole cooked lobsters and having them shipped in warm weather. So I was pleased that they arrived in perfect condition and made delicious easting. If you are willing to do the disassembling, this is a cheaper alternative to lobster meat already shelled.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Hello, Thank you for sharing your experience! We’re so glad to hear the whole cooked lobsters arrived in perfect condition and that you enjoyed them. You’re absolutely right — if you don’t mind doing the disassembling, they make a delicious and more economical alternative to pre-shelled lobster meat. We’d love to show our appreciation by sending you a gift card for your next order. Please email us at [email protected] , and our team will take care of the details for you. All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Herc
Jul 30, 2025
Incredibly great taste and meticulously…
Incredibly great taste and meticulously packed arrived on time will definitely buy this again🕺
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Herc, Thank you for the awesome feedback! We’re thrilled to hear everything arrived on time, perfectly packed, and tasting great. Can’t wait to serve you again soon — we’ll have the seafood ready whenever you are! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
James H.
Jul 17, 2025
Delivered fast and good quality. I'll buy more for sure when I need it.
Delivered fast and good quality. I'll buy more for sure when I need it.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comJul 29, 2025
We’re so glad to hear your order arrived quickly and met your expectations in quality. We’ll be here whenever you're ready for your next seafood order! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Sjones
Jul 9, 2025
Best Lump Crab meat around!
Best Lump Crab meat around! All Fresh seafood's lump crab meat is so fresh and versatile and you can't beat the price! I have used it in a seafood pot pie, as a lump crab cocktail and even with Steak Oscar. The lump crab come in 1 pound containers perfect for any meal so if you grab multiple pounds you don't have to worry about separating the crab. I love All Fresh Seafood and I have never been disappointed!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comJul 29, 2025
Thank you so much for the amazing review! We’re thrilled to hear how much you’re enjoying our lump crab meat — and wow, seafood pot pie, crab cocktail, and Steak Oscar? That all sounds delicious! We love that you’re making the most of the 1-pound containers, and we’re honored to be your go-to for quality seafood. Your continued support means the world to us! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Theodore VanNort, J.
Jul 9, 2025
Lobster claw and knuckle meat
The lobster claw and knuckle meat I ordered from All Fresh Seafood was great The meat was sweet and tender and reminded me of the lobster meat I had at numerous lobster shack in Maine I'll definitely order this again!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comJul 29, 2025
Dear Theodore, Thank you for the fantastic review! We’re so happy to hear the claw and knuckle meat brought back memories of Maine lobster shacks — that’s the highest compliment we could hope for! Sweet, tender, and satisfying is exactly what we aim to deliver. We can’t wait to send more your way! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Michael W.
Jun 13, 2025
Pesto sauce makes the difference
The pesto sauce comes with and pairs magnificently the Shellabration prepared scallop meal. These aren’t your typical microwave meals. They are more like a meal prepared by a top chef. The pesto sauce adds the finishing touch making the meal one of my favorites.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comJul 29, 2025
Thank you so much for the thoughtful review! We're delighted to hear you enjoyed the Shellabration prepared scallop meal — especially with the pesto sauce! We put a lot of care into making sure our meals feel chef-crafted, even when they’re ready in minutes. Knowing it’s become one of your favorites truly means a lot to us. Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report