Allfreshseafood.com Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of allfreshseafood.com

Allfreshseafood.comReviews of allfreshseafood.com

4.2213 reviews
Meat, Seafood & Eggs
89 East 42nd St, New York, New York

Call Directions Website

Allfreshseafood.com

About Allfreshseafood.com

The best part of All Fresh Seafood is that we have made it as simple as possible. We have an online store strictly dedicated to our national customers. From sushi-grade salmon and tuna to mussels, scallops, oysters, and more, we can ship our fresh seafood anywhere in the nation.But it doesn’t stop there. We also offer a wide selection of our chef-crafted seafood meals as well as a vast array of seafood products, cooking essentials, and assorted grocery items.To get started, simply visit the All Fresh Seafood online superstore, select what items you’d like, and place your order. And if you have questions about our national shipping, wholesale orders, or our seafood in general, we’ll be happy to help. Simply fill out our contact form to get started.

Allfreshseafood.com (allfreshseafood.com) has 213 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.

Website: allfreshseafood.com
Category: Meat, Seafood & Eggs
Location: New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 54% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

PJ Lobster House
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Port Jefferson, New York
New
1 review
1
OceanBox
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · New York
New
3 reviews
3
Great Moose Woodcraft
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Wells, Maine
Excellent
70 reviews
70
OC Wild Seafood
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Huntington Beach, California
Excellent
386 reviews
386

Allfreshseafood.com reviews

Showing 165 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

Eric R.
Sep 24, 2025
Copper River Sockeye - fantastic!
Copper River salmon is expensive but worth every penny. It came super fresh - completely clean smell. Baked to just done, served with some beurre blanc. Delicious!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Eric, Thank you for sharing your experience! We couldn’t agree more — Copper River salmon is truly special, and we’re delighted to hear it arrived fresh and cooked up perfectly for you. Paired with beurre blanc sounds absolutely delicious! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Priya C.
Sep 24, 2025
Definitely going to be a regular customer!
What an incredible next day air service! Arrived sooner than expected in exquisitely wrapped and packed presentation locking in all the freshness. I will definitely stay a regular customer.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Priya, Thank you so much for the wonderful feedback! We’re thrilled to hear your order arrived so quickly and in perfect condition. Making sure every package locks in the freshness is always our top priority. We’re excited to have you as a regular customer! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Andrea S.
Sep 21, 2025
Great dumpling appetizers!
I recently steamed the shrimp dumplings and the lobster dumplings as appetizers for dinner with a few friends and they were a big hit! Will definitely order again.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Andrea, We’re so glad to hear the shrimp and lobster dumplings were a big hit at your dinner! They make such a perfect appetizer, and we’re thrilled you and your friends enjoyed them. We look forward to sending you more next time! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
jeremy M.
Sep 20, 2025
I purchase Faroe Island salmon from Allfreshseafood
I purchase Faroe Island salmon from Allfreshseafood at least twice yearly and I am always extremely happy with the quality of the salmon and the care taken in packaging and getting the salmon to me fresh, fresh, fresh! I think Faroe Island salmon is among the best salmon available and Allfreshseafood's Faroe Island salmon is better than any other Faroe Island salmon that I have had, and I have tried several other different companies. It also keeps well in the freezer until I am ready to make another purchase.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Jeremy, Thank you so much for your thoughtful review and for being such a loyal customer! We’re delighted to hear how much you enjoy our Faroe Island salmon and the care we take in packaging it. Knowing you’ve tried other companies and still find ours to be the best means the world to us. We look forward to providing you with the same fresh, fresh, fresh experience every time! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Jodie P.
Sep 20, 2025
Lovely, Luscious Lobster!
I am the first to admit that I'm a bit of a flavor snob. Having said that . . . this is THE MOST AMAZING AND DELIGHTFUL LOBSTER I HAVE EVER HAD!!! That's not hyperbole! This meat was the epitome of what lobster can and should be. Please don't hesitate to try it - it will NOT disappoint.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Jodie, Wow — thank you for such an incredible review! We’re thrilled to hear our lobster exceeded even a flavor snob’s expectations. 😊 It means so much to know you found it to be the epitome of what lobster should be. We can’t wait to serve you again with more amazing seafood experiences! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
David
Sep 19, 2025
The very best online seafood.
I have never been disappointed. I am not sure how long i have been ordering from AFS. I have never been disappointed. I have tried almost everything they have to off. They are number one in my book ! Give them a try. It’s really good eats!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear David, Thank you for your heartfelt words and longtime support! It means so much to know you’ve tried so many of our offerings and have never been disappointed. We’re honored to be number one in your book and look forward to continuing to serve you the very best in fresh seafood. All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Paul
Sep 18, 2025
Wonderful customer service and great products.
Purchased the Lobster meat which was well packaged and overall a wonderful selection. I had an issue with FedEx delivery, however All Fresh Customer Service was great and made it right. Super product and service. We’ll definitely buy again.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Paul, Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re glad to hear you enjoyed the lobster meat and that our team was able to make things right with your delivery. Your satisfaction means the world to us, and we look forward to sending you more fresh seafood soon! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report
Joseph C.
Sep 16, 2025
5 Star Company
Quality products, excellent service and delivery
Response from Allfreshseafood.comSep 28, 2025
Dear Joe, Thank you so much for your kind words! We’re delighted to know you’re happy with our products, service, and delivery. We look forward to serving you again soon! All the best! Team All Fresh Seafood – Customer Support
Report