Allfreshseafood.com Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of allfreshseafood.com

Allfreshseafood.comReviews of allfreshseafood.com

4.2213 reviews
Meat, Seafood & Eggs
89 East 42nd St, New York, New York

Call Directions Website

Allfreshseafood.com

About Allfreshseafood.com

The best part of All Fresh Seafood is that we have made it as simple as possible. We have an online store strictly dedicated to our national customers. From sushi-grade salmon and tuna to mussels, scallops, oysters, and more, we can ship our fresh seafood anywhere in the nation.But it doesn’t stop there. We also offer a wide selection of our chef-crafted seafood meals as well as a vast array of seafood products, cooking essentials, and assorted grocery items.To get started, simply visit the All Fresh Seafood online superstore, select what items you’d like, and place your order. And if you have questions about our national shipping, wholesale orders, or our seafood in general, we’ll be happy to help. Simply fill out our contact form to get started.

Allfreshseafood.com (allfreshseafood.com) has 213 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.

Website: allfreshseafood.com
Category: Meat, Seafood & Eggs
Location: New York, New York
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 54% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

PJ Lobster House
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Port Jefferson, New York
New
1 review
1
OceanBox
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · New York
New
3 reviews
3
Great Moose Woodcraft
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Wells, Maine
Excellent
70 reviews
70
OC Wild Seafood
Meat, Seafood & Eggs · Huntington Beach, California
Excellent
386 reviews
386

Allfreshseafood.com reviews

Showing 165 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters

Gary M.
Feb 9, 2025
Best Tilapia Filets
We have tried the tilapia filets several times and consider them the very best you can buy online ! So we recently tried the Crusted Tilapia filets and wow!,,they did not disappoint either! The breading was exceptional and we have tried both fried and baked We highly recommend them.
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 25, 2025
Wow, Gary! We love hearing that our tilapia fillets have become a favorite in your home! It’s fantastic that you enjoyed the Crusted Tilapia as well—whether fried or baked, it’s definitely a delicious choice. Your high recommendation means the world to us, and we truly appreciate your support. Looking forward to bringing more great seafood to your table! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
SJ M.
Feb 6, 2025
All the seafood is fresh and delicious…
All the seafood is fresh and delicious !! I especially enjoyed the shrimp marinated with Greek seasoning and the fresh lobster claw and knife meat is fantastic !!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 25, 2025
Dear SJ, Thank you for your wonderful review! We’re so happy to hear that you’re enjoying our fresh seafood, especially the Greek-seasoned shrimp and lobster claw & knuckle meat—both excellent choices! It’s always our goal to deliver the freshest, most delicious seafood, and we’re thrilled to know we hit the mark. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you again soon! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Natalia D.
Feb 5, 2025
Ordered wild mackerel
Ordered wild mackerel, salmon, and cod, and all were fresh, flavorful and of excellent quality - highly recommend!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 28, 2025
Dear Natalia, Thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the wild mackerel, salmon, and cod—freshness and quality are what we’re all about! We truly appreciate your recommendation and look forward to serving you again soon! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Cheryl M.
Jan 30, 2025
ALLFRESH SEAFOOD was more than great!
ALLFRESH SEAFOOD was more than great!! We bought the super colossal crab legs and they certainly did not disappoint. With super-fast shipping too and packaged in dry ice so well, I could not have been happier!!!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 25, 2025
Wow, Cheryl! We’re so happy to hear that you loved the super colossal crab legs! They’re definitely a showstopper, and we’re thrilled they didn’t disappoint. We take great care in packaging and shipping to ensure everything arrives fresh and perfect, so it’s wonderful to know you were pleased. Thank you for your support—we can’t wait to serve you again! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Janet G.
Jan 30, 2025
My first purchase was for New Year’s…
My first purchase was for New Year’s Eve. Price was right, delivery was as stated, lobsters were beautiful and delicious. I especially liked getting a recipe with my lobsters. It won’t be my only order!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 25, 2025
Dear Janet, Thank you for choosing us for your New Year’s Eve celebration! We’re so glad to hear the lobsters were beautiful and delicious—it’s always special to ring in the new year with great seafood. And we love that you enjoyed the recipe, too! We look forward to serving you again and making every order just as wonderful. See you next time! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Kathleen R E.
Jan 29, 2025
I have nothing bad to say about…
I have nothing bad to say about Allfreshseafood. Love their food and shipping service. Everything we have ordered has been fantastic. I even have my neighbors buying…
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 25, 2025
Hey Kathleen, Wow, thank you for your kind words and for spreading the love! It means so much to us that you’re enjoying our seafood and sharing it with your neighbors—that’s the highest compliment we could ask for. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to serving you (and your neighbors!) again soon! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
Melva M.
Jan 29, 2025
The lobster risotto puffs they are…
The lobster risotto puffs they are really really good. My familyloves them. I had a taste for something different and these lobster risotto putts hit the spot they were very good, so tasty and very flavorful OMG!
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 28, 2025
Dear Melva, Thank you for your fantastic review! We're so glad you and your family loved the lobster risotto puffs. It’s great to hear they hit the spot when you were craving something different! 😋🦞 We appreciate your support and can’t wait to serve you again! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report
John Bwman, Low Cost I.
Jan 24, 2025
excellence is evident in their dealings and customer service…
These guys are always up to the challenge and go way above the norm. everything is always right on time and Everything arrived exactly when the date selected well prepared the boxes, beautiful frozen ready to go in the fridge or freezer and the quality just off the chart as far as I’m concerned all fresh is off the chain so good thank you John in Florida
Response from Allfreshseafood.comFeb 28, 2025
Thank you, John! We truly appreciate your kind words and support. It’s great to hear that everything arrived perfectly and that you’re loving the quality! We always strive to go above and beyond, and your feedback means the world to us. Looking forward to serving you again! Team All Fresh Seafood - Customer Support
Report